timothea proofs

This commit is contained in:
Alexandros Tsakos 2023-05-04 16:34:18 +02:00
parent ac5b9319df
commit 064e9845c8
5 changed files with 35 additions and 27 deletions

View file

@ -6,7 +6,7 @@ abstract: First edition of a Christian epitaph in Greek of a woman, Timothea, br
keywords: ["Christian Nubia", "epigraphy", "epitaph", "Greek", "Brooklyn Museum", "Henry J. Anderson", "Abraham", "Timothea"] keywords: ["Christian Nubia", "epigraphy", "epitaph", "Greek", "Brooklyn Museum", "Henry J. Anderson", "Abraham", "Timothea"]
--- ---
# Introduction: From Nubia to Brooklyn # Introduction: From Nubia to Brooklyn [^1]
Among the hundreds of artifacts collected by Dr. Henry J. Anderson Among the hundreds of artifacts collected by Dr. Henry J. Anderson
(1799--1875) on his travels in the eastern Mediterranean in 1847 is a (1799--1875) on his travels in the eastern Mediterranean in 1847 is a
@ -31,12 +31,27 @@ Expedition, the occasion for his eastern travels.[^3] Along with nearly
unwrapping was the occasion for lectures delivered by Anderson at the unwrapping was the occasion for lectures delivered by Anderson at the
New-York Historical Society in December 1864 (fig. 1), reported in major New-York Historical Society in December 1864 (fig. 1), reported in major
newspapers at the time---,[^4] the stone was donated by Anderson's sons newspapers at the time---,[^4] the stone was donated by Anderson's sons
E. Ellery and Edward H. Anderson to the Society in 1877.[^5] There the E. Ellery and Edward H. Anderson to the Society in 1877.[^5]
![New-York Historical Society Lecture on Egypt, 1864: Concluding Lecture by Prof. Henry J. Anderson. Poster. New-York Historical Society Pictorial Archives, RG-5, Series IV, 2NW, Range 12A, Bay B, Drawer 10, F:1. Photography ©New-York Historical Society (http://nyhistory.org).](../static/images/zellmann/Fig1.jpg "New-York Historical Society Lecture on Egypt, 1864: Concluding Lecture by Prof. Henry J. Anderson. Poster. New-York Historical Society Pictorial Archives, RG-5, Series IV, 2NW, Range 12A, Bay B, Drawer 10, F:1. Photography ©New-York Historical Society (http://nyhistory.org).")
**~~Figure 1. New-York Historical Society Lecture on Egypt, 1864: Concluding Lecture by Prof. Henry J. Anderson. Poster. New-York Historical Society Pictorial Archives, RG-5, Series IV, 2NW, Range 12A, Bay B, Drawer 10, F:1. Photography ©New-York Historical Society (http://nyhistory.org).~~**
There the
stele (fig. 2) received the inventory number O.127An, reflected in a stele (fig. 2) received the inventory number O.127An, reflected in a
label still attached to its back (fig. 3). It may be among the "Four label still attached to its back (fig. 3). It may be among the "Four
Stones with Greek inscriptions" mentioned in an unnumbered inventory of Stones with Greek inscriptions" mentioned in an unnumbered inventory of
the Anderson gift printed in 1915.[^6] the Anderson gift printed in 1915.[^6]
![Epitaph of Timothea. Brooklyn Museum accession 37.1827E; ex-New-York Historical Society O.127An. Photography: the author.](../static/images/zellmann/Fig2.jpg "Epitaph of Timothea. Brooklyn Museum accession 37.1827E; ex-New-York Historical Society O.127An. Photography: the author.")
**~~Figure 2. Epitaph of Timothea. Brooklyn Museum accession 37.1827E; ex-New-York Historical Society O.127An. Photography: the author.~~**
![Epitaph of Timothea, back side. Photography: the author.](../static/images/zellmann/Fig3.jpg "Epitaph of Timothea, back side. Photography: the author.")
**~~Figure 3. Epitaph of Timothea, back side. Photography: the author.~~**
Anderson himself never published an account of how he came into Anderson himself never published an account of how he came into
possession of this stele or any other antiquities from Egypt or its possession of this stele or any other antiquities from Egypt or its
vicinity. Other sources, however, firmly establish a visit in late 1847 vicinity. Other sources, however, firmly establish a visit in late 1847
@ -94,9 +109,6 @@ euphemistic verb of death, the date, and a prayer for a divine grant of
repose (with ἀναπαύω) in the "bosoms" (ἐν κόλποις and variants) of repose (with ἀναπαύω) in the "bosoms" (ἐν κόλποις and variants) of
Abraham and, usually, his successor patriarchs Isaac and Jacob.[^12] Abraham and, usually, his successor patriarchs Isaac and Jacob.[^12]
Table 1. Greek epitaphs from northern Nubia with the same formulary as
the Brooklyn Museum stele, by provenance. (Names are presented without
normalization.)
||| |||
|:---|:---| |:---|:---|
@ -104,6 +116,7 @@ normalization.)
| **Talmis** | | | **Talmis** | |
||| |||
| *Epitaph of* | *References* | | *Epitaph of* | *References* |
|||
| Abraam | *I.Chr. Egypte* 623 (*SB* V 8720; *I.Nubia Tibiletti Bruno* 54) (*DBMNT* 482) | | Abraam | *I.Chr. Egypte* 623 (*SB* V 8720; *I.Nubia Tibiletti Bruno* 54) (*DBMNT* 482) |
| Akkendarpe | *I.Chr. Egypte* 622 (*SB* V 8736; *I.Nubia Tibiletti Bruno* 53) (*DBMNT* 481) | | Akkendarpe | *I.Chr. Egypte* 622 (*SB* V 8736; *I.Nubia Tibiletti Bruno* 53) (*DBMNT* 481) |
| Manna | *SEG* LII 1817 (*I.Chr. Egypte* 652; *SB* III 6089; V 8737; *I.Nubia Tibiletti Bruno* 47) (*DBMNT* 495) | | Manna | *SEG* LII 1817 (*I.Chr. Egypte* 652; *SB* III 6089; V 8737; *I.Nubia Tibiletti Bruno* 47) (*DBMNT* 495) |
@ -114,6 +127,7 @@ normalization.)
|**Talmis?**| | |**Talmis?**| |
||| |||
| *Epitaph of* | *References* | | *Epitaph of* | *References* |
|||
| Edra | *SEG* LXV 2010 (*DBMNT* 3075) | | Edra | *SEG* LXV 2010 (*DBMNT* 3075) |
| Epephanios | *SEG* XLIX 2348 (LXIII 1712) (*DBMNT* 566) | | Epephanios | *SEG* XLIX 2348 (LXIII 1712) (*DBMNT* 566) |
| Georgios | *SEG* LXVII 1472 (*DBMNT* 4398) | | Georgios | *SEG* LXVII 1472 (*DBMNT* 4398) |
@ -186,6 +200,8 @@ normalization.)
| \[\...\][^20] | Liddel, "Greek Inscriptions," pp. 97--8 no. B.2 | | \[\...\][^20] | Liddel, "Greek Inscriptions," pp. 97--8 no. B.2 |
||| |||
Table 1. Greek epitaphs from northern Nubia with the same formulary as the Brooklyn Museum stele, by provenance. (Names are presented without normalization.)
The theological implications of this plural expansion of the "bosom" The theological implications of this plural expansion of the "bosom"
(see further the commentary to line 8 of the edition below) remains to (see further the commentary to line 8 of the edition below) remains to
be explained. After the seminal passage of Luke 16, the deceased was be explained. After the seminal passage of Luke 16, the deceased was
@ -193,6 +209,10 @@ imagined---to judge from the famous illuminated manuscript of Gregory of
Nazianzus produced for the Byzantine emperor Basil I (fig. 4)---as Nazianzus produced for the Byzantine emperor Basil I (fig. 4)---as
sitting in Abraham's lap. sitting in Abraham's lap.
![Illuminated copy of Gregory of Nazianzus, scene of Dives and Lazarus. Paris, Bibliothèque nationale de France, grec 510, fol. 149r. Source: gallica.bnf.fr.](../static/images/zellmann/Fig4.jpg "Illuminated copy of Gregory of Nazianzus, scene of Dives and Lazarus. Paris, Bibliothèque nationale de France, grec 510, fol. 149r. Source: gallica.bnf.fr.")
**~~Figure 4. Illuminated copy of Gregory of Nazianzus, scene of Dives and Lazarus. Paris, Bibliothèque nationale de France, grec 510, fol. 149r. Source: gallica.bnf.fr.~~**
The publication of the Brooklyn Museum epitaph, besides encouraging the The publication of the Brooklyn Museum epitaph, besides encouraging the
continued commemoration of Timothea---an activity that the inclusion of continued commemoration of Timothea---an activity that the inclusion of
a month date in the text was meant to promote---,[^21] offers a small a month date in the text was meant to promote---,[^21] offers a small
@ -296,7 +316,7 @@ medioevale*, p. 41, lines 3--4: read Τικετη ἐτελεύτησεν in pla
line 5 with the editor \[accepted also in *I.Ghazali* 210\]\]). line 5 with the editor \[accepted also in *I.Ghazali* 210\]\]).
Corruptions, in ancient or modern copying, could also be suspected in Corruptions, in ancient or modern copying, could also be suspected in
two cases from Taphis (Ginari): of επη (sic: ἐ⟨τελευτ⟩ή⟨σεν⟩?) in the two cases from Taphis (Ginari): of επη (sic: ἐ⟨τελευτ⟩ή⟨σεν⟩?) in the
corresponding place in [Firth]{.smallcaps} 124, and of the confused corresponding place in Firth 124, and of the confused
sequence ΤΕ\[.\]ΝΑΝ\[.\]ΙΔΕΘ in *SEG* LIV 1774, which might conceal an sequence ΤΕ\[.\]ΝΑΝ\[.\]ΙΔΕΘ in *SEG* LIV 1774, which might conceal an
error (probably of copying by the editor rather than execution by the error (probably of copying by the editor rather than execution by the
ancient stonecutter) for ⟨ἐ⟩τε⟨λεύτησεν⟩. The spelling ἐτελευώθη in ancient stonecutter) for ⟨ἐ⟩τε⟨λεύτησεν⟩. The spelling ἐτελευώθη in
@ -403,20 +423,6 @@ exclusive to Ginari, but it is now found in three epitaphs from Ghazali
probably in northern Nubia, it appears alongside ἀμήν in the probably in northern Nubia, it appears alongside ἀμήν in the
corresponding place. corresponding place.
Figure 1. New-York Historical Society Lecture on Egypt, 1864: Concluding
Lecture by Prof. Henry J. Anderson. Poster. New-York Historical Society
Pictorial Archives, RG-5, Series IV, 2NW, Range 12A, Bay B, Drawer 10,
F:1. Photography ©New-York Historical Society
(\<http://nyhistory.org\>).
Figure 2. Epitaph of Timothea. Brooklyn Museum accession 37.1827E;
ex-New-York Historical Society O.127An. Photography: the author.
Figure 3. Epitaph of Timothea, back side. Photography: the author.
Figure 4. Illuminated copy of Gregory of Nazianzus, scene of Dives and
Lazarus. Paris, Bibliothèque nationale de France, grec 510, fol. 149r.
Source: gallica.bnf.fr
Bibliography Bibliography
@ -427,7 +433,7 @@ grecques*. Publications de l'Université de Lille III. Villeneuve-d'Ascq:
Université de Lille III, 1976. Université de Lille III, 1976.
*DBMNT* = Grzegorz Ochała (ed.), *Database of Medieval Nubian Texts* *DBMNT* = Grzegorz Ochała (ed.), *Database of Medieval Nubian Texts*
(Warsaw: University of Warsaw, 2011-- ) \<http://www.dbmnt.uw.edu.pl\>. (Warsaw: University of Warsaw, 2011-- ) http://www.dbmnt.uw.edu.pl.
Firth = Cecil M. Firth, "Appendix II: Catalogue of the Greek Gravestones Firth = Cecil M. Firth, "Appendix II: Catalogue of the Greek Gravestones
of the Christian Period from Ginari, Cemetery 55," in *The of the Christian Period from Ginari, Cemetery 55," in *The
@ -437,7 +443,7 @@ by grave number).
*GrEpiAbbr.* = A. Chaniotis et al., "Liste des abréviations des éditions *GrEpiAbbr.* = A. Chaniotis et al., "Liste des abréviations des éditions
et ouvrages de référence pour l'épigraphie grecque alphabétique" et ouvrages de référence pour l'épigraphie grecque alphabétique"
\<https://www.aiegl.org/grepiabbr.html\>. https://www.aiegl.org/grepiabbr.html.
*I.Chr. Egypte* = Gustave Lefebvre, *Recueil des inscriptions *I.Chr. Egypte* = Gustave Lefebvre, *Recueil des inscriptions
grecques-chrétiennes d'Égypte*. Cairo: Institut français d'archéologie grecques-chrétiennes d'Égypte*. Cairo: Institut français d'archéologie
@ -476,7 +482,7 @@ Graeca. Paris: J.-P. Migne, 1857--1866.
de Gothembourg*. Göteborgs Högskolas Årsskrift 35.1. Gothenburg: de Gothembourg*. Göteborgs Högskolas Årsskrift 35.1. Gothenburg:
Elanders, 1929. Elanders, 1929.
*P.Louvre* III = Andrea [Jördens]{.smallcaps} et al., *Griechische *P.Louvre* III = Andrea Jördens et al., *Griechische
Papyri aus der Sammlung des Louvre (P. Louvre III)*. Papyrologische Papyri aus der Sammlung des Louvre (P. Louvre III)*. Papyrologische
Texte und Abhandlungen 47. Bonn 2022. Texte und Abhandlungen 47. Bonn 2022.
@ -487,12 +493,14 @@ Aegypten*. Various places and publishers, 1915-- .
Graecum*. Leiden: Brill, 1923-- . Graecum*. Leiden: Brill, 1923-- .
*TM* = *Trismegistos: An Interdisciplinary Portal of the Ancient World* *TM* = *Trismegistos: An Interdisciplinary Portal of the Ancient World*
\<https://www.trismegistos.org\> https://www.trismegistos.org
*T.Mom.Louvre* = François Baratte and Bernard Boyaval, "Catalogue des *T.Mom.Louvre* = François Baratte and Bernard Boyaval, "Catalogue des
étiquettes de momies du Musée du Louvre," *Cahiers de Recherches de étiquettes de momies du Musée du Louvre," *Cahiers de Recherches de
l'Institut de Papyrologie et d'Égyptologie de Lille* 2--6 (1975--1981). l'Institut de Papyrologie et d'Égyptologie de Lille* 2--6 (1975--1981).
References
Brakmann, Heinzgerd, "Defunctus adhuc loquitur: Gottesdienst und Brakmann, Heinzgerd, "Defunctus adhuc loquitur: Gottesdienst und
Gebetsliteratur der untergegangenen Kirche in Nubien." *Archiv für Gebetsliteratur der untergegangenen Kirche in Nubien." *Archiv für
Liturgiewissenschaft* 48 (2006): pp. 283--333. Liturgiewissenschaft* 48 (2006): pp. 283--333.
@ -543,7 +551,7 @@ Lynch, William F. (ed.). *Official Report of the United States'
Expedition to Explore the Dead Sea and the River Jordan*. Baltimore: Expedition to Explore the Dead Sea and the River Jordan*. Baltimore:
John Murphy, 1852. John Murphy, 1852.
Mateos, J. "Prières syriennes d'absolution du VII^e^--XI^e^ siècles." Mateos, J. "Prières syriennes d'absolution du VIIe--XIe siècles."
*Orientalia Christiana Periodica* 35 (1968): pp. 252--80. *Orientalia Christiana Periodica* 35 (1968): pp. 252--80.
Monneret de Villard, Ugo. *La Nubia medioevale*, vol. 1. Cairo: Institut Monneret de Villard, Ugo. *La Nubia medioevale*, vol. 1. Cairo: Institut
@ -622,7 +630,7 @@ Lazarus in Luke 16:19--31." *Novum Testamentum* 62 (2020): pp. 2--24.
[^3]: He contributed a report, "Geological Reconnaisance of Part of the [^3]: He contributed a report, "Geological Reconnaisance of Part of the
Holy Land," on explorations from Beirut south to the Dead Sea, Holy Land," on explorations from Beirut south to the Dead Sea,
including its eastern shores (in [Lynch]{.smallcaps} \[ed.\], including its eastern shores (in Lynch \[ed.\],
*Official Report*, pp. 75--206); see also his obituary in the *New *Official Report*, pp. 75--206); see also his obituary in the *New
York Times*, 18 January 1876, p. 8. York Times*, 18 January 1876, p. 8.
@ -669,7 +677,7 @@ Lazarus in Luke 16:19--31." *Novum Testamentum* 62 (2020): pp. 2--24.
from "the domain of local law or finance": van der Vliet, from "the domain of local law or finance": van der Vliet,
"Gleanings," pp. 176--8 \[*SEG* LII 1816\]. "Gleanings," pp. 176--8 \[*SEG* LII 1816\].
[^16]: [Firth]{.smallcaps} read χρισαν̅τη; the overline in a Nubian [^16]: Firth read χρισαν̅τη; the overline in a Nubian
context would be expected to represent /i/, but a misreading (or context would be expected to represent /i/, but a misreading (or
misprinting) of χρισανθη (Chrisanthē; cf. Χρυσάνθη) is also misprinting) of χρισανθη (Chrisanthē; cf. Χρυσάνθη) is also
possible. An anonymous reader of *Dotawo* is thanked for these possible. An anonymous reader of *Dotawo* is thanked for these

Binary file not shown.

After

Width:  |  Height:  |  Size: 12 MiB

Binary file not shown.

After

Width:  |  Height:  |  Size: 1 MiB

Binary file not shown.

After

Width:  |  Height:  |  Size: 2.4 MiB

Binary file not shown.

After

Width:  |  Height:  |  Size: 1.1 MiB