1489 lines
82 KiB
Markdown
1489 lines
82 KiB
Markdown
---
|
||
title: "The Art of the Revolution: The Online and Offline Perception of
|
||
Communication during the Uprisings in Sudan in 2018 and 2019"
|
||
authors: ["roksanahajduga.md"]
|
||
abstract: The article deals with art from the Sudanese revolution in 2018 and 2019
|
||
(the December Revolution). The focus is on the most recognizable and
|
||
widespread images from the uprising and their presence on the streets of
|
||
Sudanese cities and social media. The article shows how freedom of
|
||
expression exploded on the Sudanese streets after years of censorship,
|
||
suppression, and violations of freedom of speech, media, and civil
|
||
rights. Art and social media had significant roles in covering the
|
||
uprising. Issues related to the importance and value of art in
|
||
transmitting social discourse and dissent in a tightly controlled
|
||
society are raised. These issues should be the subject of wider research
|
||
on conflict and social media in Sudan. This article focuses only on a
|
||
small part of this vast and important topic.
|
||
keywords: ["Sudan", "revolution", "uprising", "street art", "social media",
|
||
"protests", "murals", "graffiti", "images", "iconic"]
|
||
---
|
||
|
||
|
||
# Introduction
|
||
|
||
This article focuses on the images, graphics, and photos circulating on
|
||
the internet -- often photographs of murals and graffiti from the walls
|
||
of Sudanese streets. I discuss how street art manifested the discourse
|
||
of public opinion in Sudan during the revolution and how social media
|
||
became a significant part of contemporary communication. Images from
|
||
social media conveyed by the international media represented the voice
|
||
of Sudanese people outside the country. I will show how social media
|
||
helped stage events, control activities, and back the official policy of
|
||
the Sudanese government to create a different narrative of events in
|
||
Sudan. This article engages with the question of how the reach of social
|
||
media platforms has changed the nature of political disobedience, and
|
||
how it provided new tools to overcome the repression imposed by the
|
||
regime and allowed quick, safe, and anonymous going out from hiding as
|
||
public opposition.
|
||
|
||
**Methodology**
|
||
|
||
In this study, I will use an analytical approach to examine articles and
|
||
social media concerning the 2018/2019 December Revolution in Sudan.
|
||
International media used several terms to describe the events that began
|
||
in Sudan in December 2018, depending on whether the events resulted in
|
||
fundamental social changes or just political change. In my
|
||
understanding, the events in Sudan should be called a \'revolution\',
|
||
because it was a dynamic and major shift of political power and directly
|
||
related to social changes.
|
||
|
||
In this study, I employed various data collection methods, relying on an
|
||
extensive review of news articles, reports, and social media content. At
|
||
the same time, I conducted a comparative study on international media
|
||
and its interpretation of revolutionary art. I observed social media
|
||
reactions to threads related to the Sudanese revolution; spoke with
|
||
Sudanese people in Khartoum and the provinces; followed the art groups
|
||
created on the streets and online; analysed what happened to both street
|
||
and digital art after the protests ended. All of this was the basis of
|
||
the analysis of art\'s impact on the Sudanese people during the
|
||
revolution and more than two years after these events. How strong
|
||
emotional charge do they still have? For the article, I limited myself
|
||
to the artwork directly related to the causes of the revolution, its
|
||
most important events, and the participation of women, as they were
|
||
strongly represented on the streets of Sudan. Chosen street art was
|
||
posted on social media in the form of photographs, paintings, graphics,
|
||
cartoons, etc. I have chosen the most frequently reproduced artworks and
|
||
the creations that had the longest impact on public opinion, because
|
||
over time these have become symbols of the revolution.
|
||
|
||
**Politics and Social-Economic Context**
|
||
|
||
The concept of revolution and the struggle to gain freedom is not a new
|
||
phenomenon in Sudan. In 1964, the first president of Sudan, Ibrahim
|
||
Abbūd was brought down during the October revolution.[^1] In 1969, Jafar
|
||
al-Numayri overthrew the democratic rule of al-Azhari, and then was
|
||
removed from power by the popular movement in 1985.[^2] Omar al-Bashir
|
||
also came to power through a military coup in 1989.[^3] Many reasons
|
||
contributed to the revolution in 2018. As in 1964 or 1985, the political
|
||
and social situation was complex, and many of those problems are still
|
||
relevant in 2021.[^4] However, during the 30-year reign of Omar
|
||
al-Bashir, a new threat to democracy appeared while Sudan was becoming a
|
||
fundamentalist dictatorship, which led to the economic sanctions imposed
|
||
by the US and limited the inflow of foreign capital and opportunities
|
||
for economic diversification. Media censorship and the rise of Islamic
|
||
conservatism led to systemic changes dividing citizens into classes by
|
||
origin, sex, and religion. Progressive changes in the law allowed the
|
||
authorities to censor the citizens. In 2009, the Press and Publication
|
||
Acts was introduced. This law established the National Council of the
|
||
Press and Publication, which is responsible for regulating the media and
|
||
licensing the newspapers. This Council is not independent, and the
|
||
government appoints its members.[^5] During protests in 2019, 79
|
||
journalists were arrested based on this law. In 2015, Law on Access to
|
||
Information was introduced to the public, a law restricting citizens\'
|
||
access to information.[^6][^7] This was a time of high censorship and
|
||
suppression. All of this meant silencing the political opposition and
|
||
any criticism.
|
||
|
||
The independence of South Sudan in 2011, after the devastating Second
|
||
Civil War lasting 22 years, had a dramatic effect on Sudan\'s economy.
|
||
The Sudanese pound was devalued, and inflation rose to 70 per cent.
|
||
Before that, since 1999, oil fueled the economic growth in Sudan. There
|
||
was a period of relative prosperity, but the government missed this
|
||
\'oil boom\' and the opportunity to diversify the economy. Oil deposits
|
||
are mainly located in today's South Sudan, and with the secession of
|
||
South Sudan, Sudan\'s economy lost its main driving force and primary
|
||
income. In addition, US sanctions, corruption, and government
|
||
inefficiency limited any changes that would improve citizens\' lives.
|
||
The economic crisis aggravates the additional costs of fighting the
|
||
insurgents on the city streets and the continuous strengthening of the
|
||
security sector.[^8] All this resulted in currency depreciation and
|
||
hyperinflation.
|
||
|
||
Thus, in the economic crisis, the government tried to recover by
|
||
drastically reducing social financing. In 2010, the activist Mohammed
|
||
Hassan 'Al Boushi' Alim, accused Nafi' Ali Nafi, the Former Assistant to
|
||
the President, of corruption and human rights violations.[^9] Enas
|
||
Satir, the Sudanese artist, refers to this event in her work explaining
|
||
the causes of the 2018 revolution. On her Instagram profile, she writes:
|
||
"(...) Al Boushi, when facing Nafi' Ali Nafi' (...), asked him: "*Tell
|
||
me about the bread, that is now the size of an ear*". Every word uttered
|
||
by Al Boushi is as powerful today as it was years earlier.[^10] The
|
||
reduction in the size of the bread referred to by Enas Satir was
|
||
associated with the reduction in government subsidies on basic goods,
|
||
followed by an increase in grain prices. At the same time, bakers were
|
||
forbidden to raise the price of bread. Having no other choice, they
|
||
began to reduce the size of the bread. Nevertheless, bread shortages
|
||
were not the main reason leading to the uprising in 2018. The reason
|
||
should be sought in the Sudanese economy's long-term deterioration. Many
|
||
years of Islamist military regime activities have allocated more funds
|
||
to the security apparatus than to economic development strategies. The
|
||
corrupt system hit all citizens and significantly increased living
|
||
costs, such as costs of food and gas. Deteriorating living conditions
|
||
spurred the development of a strong and conscious civil society.
|
||
Professionals began forming trade unions to mobilize action for better
|
||
pay and working conditions. The protesters demanded to overthrow the
|
||
ruling National Congress Party (NCP) and a president who had held power
|
||
for three decades. Without doubt, the lack of trust in the government
|
||
and mounting tensions due to no prospects, economic collapse, and lack
|
||
of access to reliable information, forced people into the streets. In
|
||
2013, 2014, and 2016, the police and the military brutally crushed the
|
||
strikes in Khartoum.
|
||
|
||
In December 2018, the government, wanting to save the country from
|
||
financial collapse, gave up subsidies for bread and fuel, which caused
|
||
public outrage and started protests.[^11] These austerity measures were
|
||
initially introduced in smaller cities. The government believed that the
|
||
citizens from outside the urban areas would accept the measures without
|
||
protests because they wouldn't be able to mobilize. That is why the
|
||
protests started in Atbara and other smaller cities. Before the protest
|
||
moved to the capital, the people united in these smaller cities to
|
||
demand radical political and social change. Referring to these events,
|
||
artist Abdul Rahman Al Nazeer released '[The Bread
|
||
Loaf](https://bit.ly/2SAtQhO)' (Figure 1), inspired by Michelangelo's
|
||
painting 'The creation of Adam'.[^12] In the original, God stretches out
|
||
his hand towards Adam sitting in Eden. His hand has an outstretched
|
||
finger to transfer the spark of creation to Adam. This image has
|
||
penetrated pop culture worldwide, and the symbol of conveying the
|
||
'divine particle' or 'spark of life' is often paraphrased in visual
|
||
artworks. For Abdul Rahman, this scene takes place at a typical Sudanese
|
||
bus station -- a Sudanese pound in God's hand, which symbolizes the
|
||
spark of life necessary for human survival. In waiting for being
|
||
created, Adam's limp hand holds a bread loaf.
|
||
|
||
The uprising started with the protests in Atbara, home of the Railway
|
||
Workers Union, the most vital trade union in Sudan and the libertarian
|
||
driving force that fuelled the 1964 and 1985 uprisings.[^13] Responsible
|
||
for the protests\' organized activities, the Sudanese Professionals
|
||
Association, established in 2018, follows the Union tradition.[^14]
|
||
Entry in Khartoum of a train from Atbara full of people chanting: "*The
|
||
dawn has come, Atbara has arrived*" has become one of the 2018-2019
|
||
revolt symbols. This event is also a reference to the October 1964
|
||
strike, when citizens from Kassala boarded their freedom train to
|
||
Khartoum to help oust General Abbūd from power (Figure 2).[^15] One of
|
||
the most recognizable images of the train is the art piece by Mounir
|
||
Khalil (Figure 3), which captures the joy of the people on the train and
|
||
the tense anticipation of the crowd gathering at the tracks.[^16]
|
||
Hussein Merghani (Figure 4) immortalized this moment in a painting
|
||
showing hundreds of people welcoming the train filled with waving flags.
|
||
Merghani's painting exudes strength, energy, and a sense of community --
|
||
it reflects the atmosphere in Sudan during the revolution.[^17]
|
||
|
||
Protests broke out in Sudan in December 2019, calling for the stepdown
|
||
of President Omar al-Bashir and his regime.[^18] In particular, large
|
||
numbers of young people, especially women, took to the streets. The
|
||
mobilization of people in Atbara began the pursuit of political change
|
||
for the entire nation. On December 19, girls from one of the schools in
|
||
Atbara marched in one of the largest markets in the city chanting
|
||
slogans against cutting subsidies. This was the result of increasing
|
||
grain and bread prices and thus increasing prices for school meals. The
|
||
girls were joined by others, and photos from the demonstration quickly
|
||
circulated on social media and sparked protests in al-Gedarif, Madani
|
||
(near Khartoum), Nyala (Darfur), and Port Sudan.[^19] Contrary to the
|
||
uprisings of 1964 and 1985, where trade unions played a leading role,
|
||
the uprisings in 2013, and especially that of 2018, were driven by
|
||
masses of young people and activists organizing protests and providing
|
||
up-to-date information. As far as the uprising of 2019 is concerned, the
|
||
protest had a unique character because they were a combination of
|
||
efforts by professional and social groups -- those that were first
|
||
mobilized in 2013, community-based structures and initiatives training
|
||
from the beginning in non-violent civil engagement. The Sudanese
|
||
Professional Association (SPA) showed extraordinary leadership skills,
|
||
however, it was the involvement of civil society that made it possible
|
||
to sustain a decentralized campaign based on non-violent protests. The
|
||
collaboration of local groups and trade unions (which always were a very
|
||
strong part of civil society organizations) was particularly noticeable.
|
||
SPA mobilized the people and actively participated in the activities
|
||
against al-Bashir\'s regime, as during previous revolutions in which
|
||
professional organizations took an active part. However, despite the
|
||
similarities, the situation in 2019 was different due to the
|
||
organizational structure. Decentralized activities in social media
|
||
influenced the spread of information and mobilization of people across
|
||
the country. Youth became more politically involved and joined
|
||
volunteers and professional associations in training and organizing
|
||
civil society during the protests. Even threats of arrest and attacks on
|
||
protesters did not stop Sudanese citizens from going out in the streets.
|
||
The dramatic situation in which the Sudanese found themselves and the
|
||
exhaustion of their trust in the government is shown in Khalid Albaih's
|
||
artwork (Figure 5).[^20] In his graphic, people are queuing for bread
|
||
and other necessities and this queue ends with a bomb. The graphic is
|
||
inspired by everyday life because people are forming a tight queue.
|
||
There is already a fuse lit at the end of the queue, illustrating that
|
||
citizens' patience has its limits, that the process of social awakening
|
||
has already started, and that there is no turning back.
|
||
|
||
In the face of widespread frustration and anger, president al-Bashir
|
||
dissolved the government and appointed military officers in its place to
|
||
avoid stepping down from power. However, on April 10, a military coup
|
||
led to his resignation. History has come full circle, and al-Bashir was
|
||
removed from power the same way that he seized power 30 years earlier.
|
||
The protests continued as the army that forced al-Bashir to step down
|
||
was engaged in the Transitional Military Council (TMC), chaired by
|
||
General Mohamed Hamdan Dagalo, also known as Hemeti.[^21] Hemeti is
|
||
known in Sudan for his ties to The Rapid Support Forces (RSF), a
|
||
paramilitary group descended from the infamous Janjaweed militias.
|
||
Protesters demanded civilian participation in the transitional
|
||
government and the dissolution of TMC. Among the protesters were young
|
||
women seen on the frontline of the marches, women whose rights were
|
||
systematically violated by the Bashir regime. Female protesters have
|
||
been verbally and sexually harassed by the police and security forces.
|
||
This meant that each of the protesting women had to face great fear.
|
||
They had to be strong, and their strength emanated from the other women
|
||
sharing the struggle. Each woman shouting anti-government slogans led
|
||
masses of protesters behind her.
|
||
|
||
The protests continued nationwide despite the increasing acts of
|
||
aggression from the armed forces. On June 3, the RSF cordoned off sit-in
|
||
protesters and used firearms. This attack on peaceful protesters in
|
||
front of the military headquarters in Khartoum resulted in the killing
|
||
of at least 127 people, and the attack is called the Khartoum
|
||
massacre.[^22] The RSF could not have acted on their own, and it seems
|
||
that the TMC had approved the attack. Khartoum was cut off from the
|
||
world by an internet blackout. Suddenly, all social media platforms
|
||
updating daily on the situation in Sudan went silent. There was no
|
||
possibility to use traditional media, television did not broadcast
|
||
information, and newspapers were suspended. Acts of violence escalated,
|
||
and shocking descriptions of attacks, shootings of protesters, and rapes
|
||
of women appeared in reports of witnesses calling for international
|
||
help.[^23] Increasing social tensions prolongated peace talks that were
|
||
completed with the signing of the Draft Constitutional Declaration on
|
||
August 4 by the Forces of Freedom and change -- consisting of the
|
||
uprising movement and the TMC.[^24] The agreement stipulated that a
|
||
Transitional Government of four civilians and three military officers
|
||
would oversee changes in the country during a three-year transition
|
||
period. The declaration did not contain specific economic reforms,
|
||
specific mandates to improve the rights of women and youth, any plan to
|
||
prosecute those guilty of war crimes, or a rigorous investigation into
|
||
the June 3 massacre.[^25] However, changes began with dissolving
|
||
al-Bashir\'s NCP party and the repealing of the Public Order Act[^26],
|
||
which targeted women drastically and restricted their freedom.[^27]
|
||
Female Genital Mutilation (FGM) was prohibited under penalty of
|
||
imprisonment.[^28]
|
||
|
||
Strikes are over, but the Sudanese still fear that history will repeat
|
||
itself and that the military will try again to usurp power.
|
||
Democratization in Sudan has begun, but the elites associated with
|
||
al-Bashir's regime can slow down the process significantly. The failure
|
||
to include social and economic reforms in the constitution may
|
||
compromise the main postulates of the movement. The agreement also
|
||
avoids issues of war and peace, racism, and the marginalization of
|
||
minorities and refugees. However, solving such important and challenging
|
||
problems requires time and careful observation of the government\'s
|
||
actions, and Sudanese activists seem to be watching. Such a high civic
|
||
mobilization may allow the building of a strong democracy because public
|
||
opinion will hold both transitional and elected political leaders
|
||
accountable. The Constitutional Charter from 2019 established a
|
||
government consisting of a civilian cabinet, a Sovereignty Council, and
|
||
a Legislative Council. Decisions regarding domestic and foreign policy
|
||
are taken by Lieutenant General Abdel Fattah al-Burhan, the head of the
|
||
army and the chairman of the Sovereign Council, which bypasses civilian
|
||
leadership and calls for the dissolution of the government. Meanwhile,
|
||
citizens continue to demand a civilian government with full executive
|
||
powers.
|
||
|
||
**Art beyond Divisions and Prejudices**
|
||
|
||
The core of the uprising and the source of its strength was the equality
|
||
of all Sudanese people. No protests in Sudan had previously included
|
||
every ethnic group and social class included. The Sudanese have
|
||
emphasized that not only the people of Khartoum took protests to the
|
||
streets, but also the peoples of Kordofan, Nuba Mountains, and Darfur.
|
||
In a video from the protests, a woman chants: "*From Kordofan \[the
|
||
revolution\] has emerged after we have been hit by gunfire. This is a
|
||
government with no feelings... and the Nuba mountains, like Darfur,
|
||
their blood is very expensive. We will protect our land, oh farmer. Our
|
||
Sudan will be set free!*"[^29] Three decades of hate speech used on
|
||
generations of people was an easy and effective way to turn people
|
||
against each other. NCP promoted ethnic, religious, and social
|
||
discrimination and justified hatred and violence against minorities and
|
||
refugees. Government propaganda polarizing the country aroused distrust
|
||
between different ethnic groups while emphasizing the supremacy of
|
||
Sudan\'s Arabic-speaking Muslims at the same time. Ethnic identification
|
||
has been used by al-Bashir\'s regime for decades, dividing the country
|
||
and fuelling inequality. During the civil war in Darfur, the rebel
|
||
tribes were called by the government "Black Africans". In opposition to
|
||
them, the Sudan army was identified as Arabs.[^30] Attempts to implement
|
||
the same ethnical division on young people impacted the social response
|
||
and became a double-edged weapon. The opposite, as expected, brought
|
||
people closer under the slogan: "We want a country free of racism!"
|
||
(Figure 6)[^31] Young activists created a new quality of communication
|
||
and collective disobedience. No one felt excluded, and a concept of
|
||
peaceful demonstrations, so different from the terror used by the
|
||
security apparatus, appealed to all people. Perversely, al-Bashir\'s
|
||
rule formed a fertile ground for the unification of all Sudanese people
|
||
and pushed them to act as one.
|
||
|
||
The long-lasting civil war in Darfur was used as a government excuse for
|
||
the deepening economic crisis and the stricter racist policy towards
|
||
non-Arabs.[^32] During the sit-in, protesters have often stressed that,
|
||
as a result of long-term government campaigns targeting ethnic
|
||
minorities, the division of society is a severe problem.[^33] Currently,
|
||
there are studies on the Arab Islamist Sudanese government inspiring the
|
||
conflict in Darfur.[^34] In 2018, the government accused ten young
|
||
Darfur men of planning a terrorist attack on protesters on the streets
|
||
of Khartoum. According to public records, they planned to use self-made
|
||
bombs. The plot was exposed in social media and showcased the same
|
||
race-based politics that the al-Bashir regime was known for. The friends
|
||
of the young Darfurians identified them as peaceful students rather than
|
||
terrorists.[^35] In response to such a despicable attempt to spark
|
||
ethnic riots, protesters called for unification with a special message
|
||
to the government: You racist egomaniac! We are all Darfur![^36] As a
|
||
counter-narrative to the regime propaganda, artists embraced Sudan's
|
||
cultural diversity and appreciation for uniting differences. One of the
|
||
murals by Mughira, a fine arts student, shows a series of figures
|
||
standing next to each other in traditional and contemporary clothes and
|
||
headgear -- symbolizing participation in protests regardless of origin
|
||
(Figure 7).[^37]
|
||
|
||
Racism in Sudan is a complex issue due to the mixture of various
|
||
populations. Deep-rooted racism, discrimination, and intolerance are the
|
||
results of years of government propaganda emphasizing racial and ethnic
|
||
superiority. With the spread of the internet, propaganda moved to social
|
||
media. Pages responsible for spreading ethnic propaganda were often
|
||
exposed on Facebook during the revolution in 2019. Sudanese knew the
|
||
regime's methods and remembered many cases when fake news and hate
|
||
speech started violence between ethnic groups, especially in the
|
||
South.[^38] The exclusionary policy not only covered non-Arab tribes but
|
||
also women, who were the primary victims of the Public Order Act.[^39]
|
||
Coupled with physical and verbal abuse, women were gradually forced out
|
||
of society.[^40] Women were in the front of the protests from the first
|
||
day of the revolution; they became symbols of strength and muses for the
|
||
artists. 60-70% of the participants were women, so there is a reason why
|
||
this revolution is often described as the Women\'s Revolution.[^41]
|
||
Women inspired artists with their steadfastness when facing the
|
||
oppressive army officers, strength during the long sit-in and ululation,
|
||
kindness, and readiness to help the wounded and those in need. Female
|
||
artists\' perspective was crucial for showing women's everyday life
|
||
without beautifying it and of priceless value for understanding their
|
||
motivation and hopes. The artist Almoger Abdulbagey painted 17 images of
|
||
walking women in traditional and contemporary clothes -- reflecting
|
||
their ethnic diversity. These abstract figures painted with vivid
|
||
colours emanate power, as reporters who witnesses the marches and
|
||
chanting described the women's presence in the demonstrations.[^42] This
|
||
is an example of how fake news targeting ethnic groups spread by the
|
||
regime backfired during the protests. Art began to express the
|
||
opposition to the state propaganda, and this became a turning point in
|
||
the perception of social divisions by the Sudanese themselves. There is
|
||
no consent to racist propaganda in these artworks.
|
||
|
||
On 8 April 2019, Lana Haroun took the photo of Alaa Salah in front of
|
||
the military headquarters in Khartoum (Figure 8). The iconic photo shows
|
||
Alaa Salah standing on the car's roof, with her hand up, leading the
|
||
chant and making the crowd cheer together.[^43] Alaa Salah was then a
|
||
22-year-old architecture student who advocated for women\'s rights. Her
|
||
photo became a symbol of protests in Sudan and sparked a new trend in
|
||
artworks focusing on women\'s rights, strength, steadfastness, and
|
||
constant motivation to get the people around them involved. Of course,
|
||
there are many photos and videos from this event. However, this photo
|
||
widely echoed around the world. Alaa Salah's white tobe is associated
|
||
with professions such as teachers, nurses, and midwives -- they adopted
|
||
it as their uniform and is still considered a modest garment for
|
||
educated and independent women. The thoughtful selection of Alaa Salah's
|
||
clothing makes reference to the tradition of Sudanese female activists
|
||
from the 1940s and 1950s, and the dress emphasizes the legacy of
|
||
women\'s fight for social justice.[^44] "*At a national conference in
|
||
1969, activist and first female member of Sudan's Parliament, Fatima
|
||
Ahmed Ibrahim, argued that women's rights were in keeping with Sudanese
|
||
traditions. As evidence of this, Ibrahim asked the audience to compare
|
||
her tobe with the western business suit of then-President Gaafar
|
||
Numeiri, who stood next to her*."[^45] The choice of the outfit was
|
||
undoubtedly a well-thought-out move and its message spread widely and
|
||
drew attention to the feminist movement in Sudan. This image of a young
|
||
student is still the most recognizable and most shared image in social
|
||
media of the 2018/2019 revolution. The only downside to the attention
|
||
the image attracted is that the focus was not on the words spoken by
|
||
Alaa Salah but only on her outfit. She was quoting the reaction of
|
||
Sudanese poet Azhari Mohamed Ali against the Public Order Act: "*They
|
||
imprisoned us in the name of religion, burned us in the name of religion
|
||
... killed us in the name of religion*".[^46] Lana Haroun's photo,
|
||
referred to as a symbol of the revolution, was repeatedly adapted and
|
||
changed by artists worldwide, sometimes in an optimistic or satirical
|
||
way, and sometimes in a more serious and sublime manner. For example, in
|
||
Ali Hamra's cartoon where Alaa Salah replaced the Statue of Liberty on
|
||
the pedestal, al-Bashir runs away in panic upon seeing her. Kesh Malek's
|
||
mural presents Alaa Salah standing among the flashes of mobile phones
|
||
commemorating the event with a slogan next to it: "*Liberty is not a
|
||
statue anymore. She is alive with flesh and blood"* (Figure 9). In an
|
||
impressionist manner, a painting by Fatima Abdullahi shows Alaa Salah
|
||
raising her arm in the air amidst a mostly female crowd of protesters,
|
||
holding their phones with a flashlight, which creates a magical glow and
|
||
gives the picture a nearly mystical expression (Figure 10). Of course,
|
||
Alaa Salah is one of the thousands of women taking part in the
|
||
revolution, standing up against uniformed men. However, this image
|
||
became viral, and Alaa Salah became an icon of the revolution, a symbol
|
||
of women\'s fights for equal rights. Thanks to her recognition, she also
|
||
became an activist raising Sudanese women\'s rights to the international
|
||
agenda. \"*Every revolution inspires another revolution,*" Alaa Salah
|
||
says in an interview, stressing that women will not hesitate to take to
|
||
the streets again when needed.[^47] A unique adaptation of Alaa Salah as
|
||
"The scent of the revolution" was created by artist Amado Alfadni
|
||
(Figure 11). He transformed Sudan's iconic Bint El Sudan perfume label
|
||
into a clever revolutionary message.[^48] A billboard with a photo of
|
||
Alaa Salah next to the sign: "My grandmother was a Kandaka." In a
|
||
powerful way, this picture emphasizes Sudanese women's strength (Figure
|
||
12).[^49] These words were also chanted during the demonstration,
|
||
empowering, and connecting generations of women walking together. On a
|
||
mural painted by artists Amir Saleh and Belal Abdelrahman it is stated:
|
||
"Our history returns back with Kandaka". It shows a woman wearing a
|
||
helmet and brandishing a sword for her enemies (Figure 13).[^50]
|
||
Sudanese artist Yasmin Elnour's Instagram account is Kandaka Khronicles.
|
||
The nickname is inspired by the Kushite queen. Her works beautifully and
|
||
harmoniously draw from Nubian traditions and combine ethnic aesthetics
|
||
with modern symbols. The art piece "Kandaka factory\" emphasizes the
|
||
participation of women in strikes (Figure 14). She traces the women\'s
|
||
ancestry back to the pyramids of Ancient Kush, where she placed the
|
||
factory producing all the brave Sudanese warriors. With the art piece
|
||
\'Women rights?\' Yasmin asks where are women\'s rights, and why are
|
||
Sudanese women second-class citizens? Yasmin Elnour writes on her
|
||
Instagram account: *\"A surprising status quo in the old stomping ground
|
||
of the Kandakes - Nubian Warrior Queens that fought off foreign powers
|
||
and steadfastly ruled the Kingdom of Kush. We cannot blindly accept
|
||
oppressive frameworks but instead carve a path of resistance, in the
|
||
glowing spirit of our female ancestors.*"[^51]
|
||
|
||
A collage by Mahammed Mahdi shows women in white tobes and modern
|
||
clothes marching with their fists raised in protest and as signs of
|
||
anger. Above them, in the air, as if freed and freely soaring upwards,
|
||
there is a woman in white and next to her the inscription: "Long live
|
||
the women's struggle!"[^52] The artist emphasizes women's daily battle
|
||
for equality, free speech, and fair governance (Figure 15).
|
||
|
||
Artist Alaa Satir focused on the socio-political aspects of women\'s
|
||
lives in Sudan. Her series of cartoons, \"*We are the revolution*\",
|
||
honours female protesters\' centrality in uplifting and sustaining the
|
||
resistance through their strength, courage, and commitment (Figure
|
||
16).[^53] In her graphic, she also refers to Sudan\'s Independence Flag,
|
||
which no longer represents the state. Gaafar Nimeiry replaced this flag
|
||
with the tricolor black-white-red flag with a green triangle at the
|
||
hoist in 1970. The Independence Flag, as seen on the Alaa Satir
|
||
graphics, resembled the flags of Rwanda and Tanzania, emphasizing the
|
||
racial diversity of Sudan and the joining of all ethnic groups, while
|
||
Nimeiry's flag derives from purely Arab aesthetics and refers to the
|
||
Sudanese Arab identity.[^54] Many protesters waved the Independence Flag
|
||
during the rallies. Its colors emphasize the combination of Arab and
|
||
African roots, which was also reflected in the people\'s outfits on the
|
||
streets. Like many young activists, Alaa Satir raised a very important
|
||
issue regarding identity and ethnicity, which was widely discussed
|
||
during the sit-in. For the first time, these matters were discussed
|
||
openly and emphasized that multi-ethnicity is what makes Sudan stronger.
|
||
In her works, Alaa Satir also shows the everyday life of protests and
|
||
the enormous influence of women who took the fight to the streets and
|
||
for whom giving up is not an option. One of the murals with the
|
||
inscription: 'We are the revolution, and the revolution continues'
|
||
portrayed women in traditional clothes with their hands raised and their
|
||
fists clenched in a gesture of victory (Figure 17).[^55] Another mural,
|
||
painted on a blue background, shows a woman with a raised hand in a sign
|
||
of victory with slogans next to this like: 'Freedom, peace, and
|
||
justice', 'Tasqut Bas' and 'Ladies, stand your ground; this is a women's
|
||
revolution' (Figure 18). The artist writes about the events in Sudan:
|
||
"*We are not here just to overthrow a political regime but the corrupt
|
||
social system that came along with it, that targeted women and used all
|
||
techniques to try and push them backwards!*"[^56]
|
||
|
||
Mergani Salih chose a different form of expression by creating a mosaic
|
||
with thousands of photos of women protesting and suffering from an
|
||
oppressive government. With dedication, he searched the Internet to
|
||
choose the right photos to create a representation of Sudan\'s
|
||
embodiment. The character is deeply rooted in Sudan folklore -- Habouba,
|
||
grandmother and caretaker. He adopted a photo of an older woman in a
|
||
traditional headdress, with a calm expression on her face, curious eyes,
|
||
and a face bearing traces of work and time -- like Sudan itself, tired
|
||
and aged but still with a sparkle in the eyes looking to the future
|
||
(Figure 19). This video mosaic is available online and even now makes an
|
||
unforgettable impression on the onlooker.[^57]
|
||
|
||
An anonymous female artist who adapted Banksy's \'Mona Lisa with rocket
|
||
launcher\' created a mural deeply inspired by pop culture. After all,
|
||
Banksy\'s London mural was referring to Da Vinci\'s 'Mona Lisa'. The
|
||
mural in Khartoum shows a figure whose outline resembles Banksy's 'Mona
|
||
Lisa', but her face is that of a Sudanese woman with a scarf on her head
|
||
and a rocket launcher in her hands (Figure 20). This simple image has a
|
||
powerful and direct message: beware of women's power.
|
||
|
||
**Online Art**
|
||
|
||
A new generation of young activists looks back to the Girifna movement,
|
||
founded by students in Khartoum in 2009, for inspiration. Their fight
|
||
shifted the protest onto completely different tracks than those known
|
||
from previous uprisings. Girifna volunteers organized just before the
|
||
elections that would take place in 2010, realizing that the society was
|
||
under-informed, and deciding to change this situation.[^58] Awareness
|
||
campaigns quickly expanded to organizing protests and publishing news
|
||
without censorship. Within a few years, these activists became the main
|
||
opposition force, and they are now visible on the political scene in
|
||
Sudan. Contemporary opposition groups significantly differ from
|
||
classical parties such as the National Umma Party, the Democratic
|
||
Unionist Party, and the Communist Party.[^59] The SPA distinguished
|
||
itself through their activities in social media, thanks to which
|
||
Sudanese people were allied to their demands. At the beginning of the
|
||
revolution, SPA formed alliances with many political parties. As a
|
||
result, 'The Forces of Freedom and Change' was formed.[^60] Very quickly
|
||
the SPA started expressing the voices of all Sudanese and published
|
||
daily on Facebook the public opinion on the current situation in Sudan.
|
||
|
||
The activists arousing political awareness among young people and
|
||
manifesting their social needs come from various regions of Sudan and
|
||
even the diaspora. Thanks to such participation of young people,
|
||
revolutionary agitation was very effectively transferred to social media
|
||
and developed countless forms of expression. These tactics have so far
|
||
been entirely ignored by political parties, but young innovative
|
||
activists identify themselves without any problems with them. Elusive on
|
||
the web, they are free to report on events in Sudan and strengthen
|
||
international support for the protesters. Online communication has been
|
||
constantly changing over the years, adapting to the situation and
|
||
guaranteeing optimal and safest oppositionist conditions. NISS (National
|
||
Intelligence and Security Service) created cyber units called *jihadist
|
||
cyber units*. Members created false accounts on Facebook or Twitter to
|
||
disinform protesters, spread propaganda, or lure individual activists
|
||
into traps. These efforts did not go unnoticed. The SPA has created
|
||
applications for contact between members and a website that broadcasts
|
||
protests live. Social media became the primary source of information
|
||
about events in Sudan and the main communication tool for
|
||
revolutionaries. One can say that they even fuelled their activities.
|
||
The regime controlled the state media and for a long time provided only
|
||
propaganda to improve its image. At the same time, information was
|
||
published on Twitter and Facebook, simultaneously translated from Arabic
|
||
to English.[^61] Al Jaili 'Jaili' Hajo is an artist who has pointed out
|
||
the lack of information about the situation in the country in the media.
|
||
In his collages, he compares public television news with photos from
|
||
protests, showing how the reality on the streets of Khartoum is
|
||
diametrically different from government propaganda broadcasted on
|
||
television (Figure 21).[^62] In one of his collages, we see people
|
||
injured after the June 3 2019 crackdown. In a manner, such artworks
|
||
replace public media, which had no information about this event.
|
||
|
||
The live-streaming massacre on 3 June 2019 was an unprecedented case
|
||
made possible by the courage of the protesters who shared photos and
|
||
videos in social media. Journalists producing "Africa Eye" for BBC have
|
||
collected several videos from the RSF\'s attack in a shocking short
|
||
documentary about the revolution.[^63] The documentary shows the
|
||
ruthless and planned actions of the militia and the terror of the
|
||
protesters. Live posts on Twitter reported a minute-by-minute escalation
|
||
of violence by the RSF. Photos showed people injured and killed on the
|
||
streets, overcrowded hospitals, and bodies pulled out from the Nile. All
|
||
this, seen almost live, confronted the world with what was happening in
|
||
Sudan in an unprecedented manner. Social media flooded with digital art
|
||
after these horrifying events. The artist Enas Satir created the series
|
||
'Kaizan and why they are bad for you' -- a compilation of drawings
|
||
explaining the origin of the word 'kaizan' (metal mug) and why the
|
||
Sudanese use it as a name for the government (see also below). This
|
||
series is aesthetically appealing and, for those from abroad, also very
|
||
informative. Enas Satir put a broader context on Sudan's situation in a
|
||
simple and clever manner.[^64] She writes on one of her drawings: "If
|
||
Sudan was a person, it would by now be gravely ill" next to a metal cup
|
||
('Kaizan') filled with blood (Figure 22).[^65]
|
||
|
||
Under al-Bashir\'s rule, any political expression was forbidden, so
|
||
artists developed a way to spread anti-government content, in an
|
||
indirect direct way. However, during the uprising, the freedom of
|
||
expression replaced all restrictions, and artists finally could speak
|
||
their minds, and via social media they could reach people anywhere.
|
||
Visual and audio-visual forms of documentation attracted a larger group
|
||
of people and had a more significant impact on the audience than TV
|
||
news. Never has such an extensive range of information resources been
|
||
used to show the power of the people in Sudan. An online mobilization
|
||
aimed at identifying the aggressors who were attacking protesters,
|
||
another unprecedented method of exercising justice. Based on photos and
|
||
videos available online, a group of women recognized the RSF officers
|
||
and published their data on Facebook. For this reason, operations'
|
||
officers began to wear masks to hide their faces and prevent their
|
||
identification.[^66]
|
||
|
||
There has been an unstoppable flow of drawings, cartoons, and memes,
|
||
fuelling the protests with bold images and intelligent retorts. This
|
||
uprising sparked a social, political, and cultural awakening that
|
||
intertwined with each other, creating an image of the marginalized
|
||
before pressing problems and underlining the power of social resistance.
|
||
In art, we can find traditional symbols and African indigenous motifs.
|
||
Also, the modern cultural references blend poetically with traditional
|
||
Sudanese aesthetics, creating bold and authentic artwork. Thanks to the
|
||
influence of tradition, so deeply rooted in Sudanese consciousness, art
|
||
reached everyone, regardless of age or origin. Artists found a way to
|
||
spread ideas and share their views in an accessible and universal way.
|
||
We can distinguish references to the history of Sudan, be it ancient
|
||
(the kingdom of Kush) or more modern (independence and earlier
|
||
revolutions). For example, a collage by Merghani Salih with a young boy
|
||
reciting poetry during protests superimposed on Kushite pyramids refers
|
||
to the ancient history of Sudan (Figure 23). It is an adaptation of the
|
||
photo entitled 'Straight Voice,' a powerful image made by Yasuyoshi
|
||
Chiba, who won World Press Photo in 2020, in the Photo of the Year
|
||
category.[^67]
|
||
|
||
A famous slogan appearing on social media: \"Make Sudan Great Again\",
|
||
on the background of monumental buildings from the Kush period, is an
|
||
ironic comment on Donald Trump's slogan "Make America Great Again", but
|
||
it also emphasized the reliance on the powerful Sudanese ancestors
|
||
dominating in north-eastern Africa during the Kushite period (Figure
|
||
24). The people of ancient Nubia were captured as slaves by Egypt. Then
|
||
the power dynamics between Nubia and Egypt shifted, and Kush ruled Egypt
|
||
as pharaohs of the 25^th^ Dynasty (about 747--656 BCE). Thus, art
|
||
teaches history; the Sudanese cannot live in chains, and they are
|
||
capable to regain their freedom. Ben Jones, with his artworks, alludes
|
||
to modern times in world history. His graphics portray al-Bashir and his
|
||
military allies as Nazis (Figure 25). It is a powerful and terrifying
|
||
combination, but it is indisputably associated with the racist rhetoric
|
||
of the NCP authorities and the genocide committed in Darfur and
|
||
Kordofan.
|
||
|
||
The global movement #BlueForSudan started in solidarity with Sudanese
|
||
martyr Mohamed Mattar, whose favourite colour was blue (Figure 26). An
|
||
artist known as Kandaka Khronicles, created a photomontage with a young
|
||
boy crying in a boat floating on a bloody river (Figure 27). It is a
|
||
homage to those killed in the crackdown and their families. The dark
|
||
blue backdrop honours Mohamed Mattar, the boy's endless tears remind of
|
||
the ongoing aggressions against peaceful protesters. Also, 'Blue Night'
|
||
by Mounir Khalil, an impressionist painting, shows people waving flags
|
||
against a starry sky background. It is a beautiful art piece full of
|
||
tranquillity and dedicated to those fallen during the uprising (Figure
|
||
28).
|
||
|
||
A graphic by Jaili Hajo is a collage of a viral photo made on the
|
||
streets of Khartoum. In a pickup truck used by security services lies a
|
||
protester knocked over on the car\'s back but still holding the Sudanese
|
||
flag high in the air. On the car roof, covered by the waving Sudanese
|
||
flag, stands an enormous figure of al-Bashir (Figure 29). He is not
|
||
essential for the artist; his face does not even deserve to be shown; he
|
||
is only a symbol of oppression. The artist thoughtfully depicts the
|
||
sense of fear that people must have felt when faced with the armed
|
||
forces. We can notice an officer with a long truncheon with a split end
|
||
on the side of the car -- the truncheon was probably used against the
|
||
crowd.[^68]
|
||
|
||
When the news broke out on social media that a NISS car killed the
|
||
3-year-old boy Muayed Yasir and seriously injured his 5-year-old
|
||
brother, people worldwide were shocked and mobilized against the
|
||
impunity of the security services in Sudan. Artists decided to react
|
||
too.[^69] The 'Hanz' graphic designer on his Twitter account condemned
|
||
this event and asked for public support to the mother of the two boys,
|
||
one of which was still in intensive care at the hospital (Figure 30).
|
||
Mustafa Alnasry created a poignant graphic of Bashir dancing on stage
|
||
during his '1 Million People March' organized to underline people\'s
|
||
support for the government. Alnasry shows the coldly calculated dance of
|
||
the President, posing as a kind leader, at the same time, ruthlessly
|
||
attacking peaceful resistants (Figure 31).[^70]
|
||
|
||
Drawings inspired by pop culture reached the most remarkable popularity
|
||
online. For example, in the work of Ibrahim Jihad (known as hxmaside),
|
||
there is a reference to the Transformers' universe of the DC comics. His
|
||
graphic entitled 'Fallen' presents the symbolic metal cup, "Kaizan" (see
|
||
above) damaged by bullets, dropped on the ground or thrown away, thus no
|
||
longer needed (Figure 32).[^71] This art piece resembles a movie poster,
|
||
and as with any poster of that kind, we can find out that "Kaizan Fall"
|
||
was produced and directed by Sudanese people -- a very clever artistic
|
||
move. Another point of inspiration from pop culture is the reference to
|
||
the KFC restaurants: The slogan "Al-jidād al-iliktrūni" means "The
|
||
electronic chicken", and it is referring to people hired by the regime
|
||
to spread fake news on the Internet. In a satirical manner, the
|
||
revolutionaries created posters portraying Omar el-Bashir on a KFC
|
||
flyer, where KFC was replaced by KEC (Kaizan Electronic Chicken) (Figure
|
||
33).[^72] Who is 'Kaizan'? It is a traditional mug made of steel and
|
||
called 'koz' (singular of Kaizan). There are different theories on why
|
||
Sudanese started calling the ruling party \'Kaizan'. Alshaheed Alimam
|
||
Alhassan Albana, the Muslim Brotherhood founder, once said: "*Knowledge
|
||
is a sea and we are its kaizan*", which back then described Muslim
|
||
Brotherhood members but now refers to Omar al-Bashir and the National
|
||
Congress Party (NCP).[^73]
|
||
|
||
Among the artists who commented on the events in Sudan were cartoonists.
|
||
Cartoons are sarcastic, often on the verge of absurdity or insult, but
|
||
their message refers often to tragic events. They have sometimes been
|
||
made without any inscriptions because the image itself is universal and
|
||
does not need any explanation. Khalid Albaih shows how General Mohamed
|
||
Hamdan Dagalo, also known as Hemeti, climbs on the corpses of the
|
||
Sudanese people to attain power (symbolized here as a throne).[^74] A
|
||
pile of bodies wrapped in shrouds is a very powerful and upsetting image
|
||
(Figure 34). In a violent manner, the artist addresses the civilian
|
||
casualties, which are part of the brutal rise of Hemeti to power in
|
||
Sudan. Hemeti, together with general Abdel Fattah al-Burhan, are
|
||
responsible for armed attacks in Darfur and took part in the war in
|
||
Yemen. Their rise to power was a blow for the Sudanese and, at the same
|
||
time, a call for mobilization to continue the struggle for democracy.
|
||
Sudanese cartoonist Boushra Al-Mujahid commented daily on the events in
|
||
Sudan. His images were always on point, clever, and understandable even
|
||
for foreigners unfamiliar with Arabic.[^75] The security forces were so
|
||
obedient that they even arrested a donkey that the protesters had marked
|
||
with revolutionary slogans. The event recorded by the phone of an
|
||
onlooker set in motion a wave of satirical cartoons ridiculing the
|
||
absurd attempts of the government to keep order on the streets. This
|
||
image transformed into all sorts of memes and cartoons to mock the
|
||
soldiers and express disrespect for their actions (Figure 35).[^76]
|
||
|
||
Participating in sit-ins was associated with the risk of an attack by
|
||
the security forces using tear gas and rubber bullets and all kinds of
|
||
physical and mental aggression. A video available online shows a group
|
||
of protesters on one side of the street and police forces on the other,
|
||
throwing tear gas canisters into a crowd. We see the brave woman Rifka
|
||
Abdel Rahman taking a tear gas canister (which is about to explode) and
|
||
throwing it back. She was named 'Bumban Catcher' ('Bumban' means tear
|
||
gas in Sudan). Merghani Salih returns to these events in his art after
|
||
the revolution using 3D models. The series is called \"Living with
|
||
Revolutionaries\" and, as he describes himself, it was created to
|
||
capture the icons of the Sudan Revolution. One of these 3D models,
|
||
posted on Merghani's Twitter account, commemorated the courage of Rifka
|
||
\'Bumban Catcher'.[^77]
|
||
|
||
**Street Art**
|
||
|
||
During the uprising, alongside regular verbal and written communication,
|
||
a flood of sketches, murals, graffiti, and cartoons spread the word
|
||
about the revolution across Sudan. Art became a platform for
|
||
transmitting information in a highly censored environment, reflecting
|
||
social tensions, and forming political discourse. Slogans were
|
||
everywhere, on people's clothes or bodies, but mainly on all urban
|
||
structures. Sudanese people expressed their emotions on the building
|
||
walls, streets, public transport, fences, and even trees and animals.
|
||
Anti-government slogans appeared in every space that it was possible to
|
||
draw, even the smallest ones. The slogan "Tasqut bas" addressed to
|
||
el-Bashir and his regime can be translated as: "Just fall, that's all"
|
||
or "You'd better fall" (Figure 36).[^78] This slogan was repeated and
|
||
hash-tagged many times on different kinds of brochures and online
|
||
flyers. Almost equally famous was: \"Ash -shaab yurid isqat an-nizam",
|
||
which means: "The people want the regime to fall".[^79] It appeared on
|
||
the buildings and bus stops not only in Khartoum but in other towns and
|
||
even villages. Activists created the hashtags #BlueForSudan and
|
||
#KeepEyesOnSudan, which appeared widely both on the streets and online.
|
||
These hashtags attracted world attention on Sudan and kept up the
|
||
mobilization in favour of the revolution. #BlueForSudan represents the
|
||
favourite colour of the martyr Mohamed Mattar, who was shot protecting
|
||
two women during a police attack (see above). Another hashtag formed
|
||
during the protests was #Sudaxit. This alluded to Brexit and emphasized
|
||
that protesters identified more with African peoples than with Arabs and
|
||
demand the separation of Sudan from the Arab League.[^80]
|
||
|
||
Due to the restrictions imposed on Internet and the censorship practised
|
||
in public television, the flow of information had to find other ways to
|
||
spread. The activists used brochures, postcards, or leaflets, sometimes
|
||
minor marks on clothes or on their bodies. That information included the
|
||
dates and places of protests, comments on current events, revolutionary
|
||
slogans or symbols, and glorifications of the martyrs. Women, for
|
||
example, used the henna painting (traditionally made before weddings)
|
||
and designed anti-government slogans or images on the hands or feet of
|
||
protesters (Figure 37 and 38).[^81] Also women wove revolution symbols
|
||
into their traditional clothes, adding victory signs or "Tasqut bas"
|
||
slogans to their toubes, which gained over the years representative
|
||
status as a reminder of feminist values fought by their mothers and
|
||
grandmothers.[^82] Older generations wore the white toube during the
|
||
previous popular uprising, which once again linked traditions with
|
||
modern times.
|
||
|
||
The artists felt responsible for showing the emotions of the Sudanese
|
||
people and spreading the revolutionary messages. Such a message can be
|
||
found on a mural in Khartoum, which is an interesting adaptation of
|
||
[Eugène'a
|
||
Delacroix](https://pl.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eug%C3%A8ne_Delacroix)', 'La
|
||
Liberté guidant le peuple' (Figure 39). The accompanying text reads: The
|
||
revolution will go on. These artworks were an expression of despair and
|
||
hope. They were born out of a desperate need for change and the
|
||
necessity of speaking the truth. Street art, impermanent and unique,
|
||
could be removed at any time, and the artists who made it were in
|
||
constant danger of being caught and imprisoned. All of this was
|
||
evanescent. It emphasized the fragility of human existence and made it
|
||
even more inclined to reflect on the values of life and what is worth
|
||
fighting for. Assil Diab, a graffiti artist, known as 'sudalove', was
|
||
one of the many female Sudanese artists courageously creating art on the
|
||
streets of Khartoum.[^83] Diab painted murals and immortalised the
|
||
memory of Sudanese killed by security forces during the uprising.
|
||
Sometimes the families were taking part in creating the martyrs\'
|
||
portraits, which allowed them to add something personally to commemorate
|
||
their loved ones (Figure 40). The portraits are reminders of the loss
|
||
and sacrifice, of government brutality and their disrespect for human
|
||
life, and the price of freedom and democracy.
|
||
|
||
One of the most high-profiled cases of police and intelligence services
|
||
brutality was the death of Ahmed al-Khair, a 36-year-old teacher from
|
||
Kashm al-Qirba. He was arrested at his home after the protest he was
|
||
taking part in and died on 2 February 2019, after a week of detention.
|
||
The police stated that the cause of Ahmed's al-Khair death was the
|
||
result of his poor health condition and was not related to his
|
||
imprisonment. However, the examination of Ahmed\'s body, first by his
|
||
family and then by pathologists, indicated death by beating and torture
|
||
to which he was subjected during the interrogation. The horrifying
|
||
details of the torture shocked and infuriated the public and Ahmed's
|
||
story was told nationwide.[^84] Sudanese still recall these events in
|
||
conversations, emphasizing that this was the turning point of the
|
||
revolution. There was nationwide mobilization and awareness that nothing
|
||
would stop the regime to silence the voice of the nation. Anger and
|
||
opposition to violence united the Sudanese people more than before.
|
||
Images of Ahmed were held by the protesters during the rallies, were
|
||
reproduced on the city\'s walls, and circulated in social media. When,
|
||
on 30 December 2020, 29 intelligence agents and police officers
|
||
responsible for Ahmed al-Khair\'s death were sentenced to death, a crowd
|
||
rallied outside the court in Omdurman. This event went down in history
|
||
as a moment of national mourning from which Sudanese rose resiliently.
|
||
After the revolution ended, Ahmed\'s story was taught in schools and
|
||
drawings of his face appeared on the walls of school buildings (Figure
|
||
41). These paintings were often painted over by the security services
|
||
but were always recreated by the people, determined and in strong
|
||
opposition to the regime\'s brutality and their efforts to censor
|
||
history.
|
||
|
||
The 3 June 2019 massacre has left a deep mark on everyone who
|
||
participated in the sit-in and watched the live streaming. RSF militia
|
||
forces opened fire on unarmed protestants, beat many of them, and raped
|
||
48 women. In their works, Galal Yousif and Amel Bashier condemned
|
||
cruelty and rape as tactics for pacifying women (Figure 42). Following
|
||
these events, the African Union degraded Sudan's rights as a
|
||
member.[^85] The daily news about atrocities committed by the RSF is
|
||
reflected in the artists\' work following these events. The mural of
|
||
Galal Yousif, destroyed during the June 3 crackdown, shows people
|
||
shouting or screaming. Above them, huge hands try to silence the figure
|
||
in the centre. The inscription in Arabic on the side explains: "You were
|
||
born free, so live free."[^86] Yousif painted several murals in
|
||
Khartoum. One of them was placed under the bridge near the sit-in and
|
||
depicts screaming figures with horrified and distorted faces (Figure
|
||
43). The incomprehensible anxiety can be compared with Edward Munch\'s
|
||
'Scream'.[^87]
|
||
|
||
Colourful murals, graffiti, sculptures, and installations within the
|
||
sit-in created a whole new space in the centre of Khartoum, a city
|
||
within a city. Space where people felt free, expressed their political
|
||
views with no fear, and experimented with new forms of artistic
|
||
expressions. It was an unprecedented phenomenon -- there has never been
|
||
such a concentration of artists from all over Sudan with different
|
||
cultural backgrounds covering various fields of fine art. Space within
|
||
the sit-in became an exhibition on a vast scale, with paintings,
|
||
graffiti, sculptures and installations, various traditional crafts,
|
||
regional costumes, poems, songs, and dances.
|
||
|
||
In the face of a military crackdown, protesters opposed the aggression
|
||
in a very clever way. They collected military equipment and reused it
|
||
differently, peacefully changing its meaning and creating an utterly
|
||
different dichotomy between them and the government forces. They made it
|
||
possible to find a bit of humour in these difficult moments and
|
||
ridiculed the militia on the other side of the barricade. Such acts gave
|
||
people a different perspective; they began to let go of fear and
|
||
regained the dignity that was taken from them by years of oppression.
|
||
Empty tear gas canisters that were used to separate protesters have been
|
||
transformed into flower vases, containers, or electrical
|
||
connectors.[^88] There was an impressive increase of photos on social
|
||
media showing an endless creativity, among these one may pick the
|
||
\"tasqut bas" slogan made with tear gas canisters (Figure 44). The
|
||
protesters were utterly changing the functions and common perceptions of
|
||
military equipment, almost straightforwardly saying objects themselves
|
||
are not dangerous but only become so in the hands of dangerous people.
|
||
An example is a photo of a ring made from a bullet (Figure 45). Art,
|
||
therefore, did not embellish reality and did not avoid showing the
|
||
violence and terror in which everyday protesters functioned.
|
||
|
||
In 2019, merchandise with symbols of the revolution started to appear in
|
||
the street markets. They were mainly produced abroad by the diaspora,
|
||
but some handmade products also circulated, albeit in a limited range,
|
||
also in Sudan: stickers, phone cases, bags or T-shirts on which symbols
|
||
and hashtags spread the message of the revolution (Figure 46). Street
|
||
art became popular and functioned as a reference to political ideas and
|
||
the current situation in the country.
|
||
|
||
**Summary**
|
||
|
||
The 2018/2019 revolution in Sudan was one of the most significant and
|
||
best-organized revolts in the Arab world in recent years. There were
|
||
large-scale protests, which showed social commitment and the
|
||
effectiveness of opposition by activists. The political engagement of
|
||
young activists changed the approach to protests in Sudan. They showed
|
||
extraordinary creativity and commitment, and thanks to that, they
|
||
reached vast sections of the society. Resistance groups, which have been
|
||
emerging since 2009, moved their activities to the streets, showing
|
||
their opposition through slogans, murals, and leaflets. Most of their
|
||
activities quickly spread online, where they joined forces with other
|
||
groups to create an efficient machine of resistance and for spreading
|
||
information without the fear of governmental censorship. Their actions
|
||
in the streets and online created a foundation for mass resistance,
|
||
which was used to the full during the protests in 2018-2019.
|
||
|
||
This article shows the phenomenon of revolutionary art in shaping public
|
||
opinion, transferring information, political discourse, and calls for
|
||
mass disobedience. The photos of the revolution, murals, and graphics
|
||
are still circulating in social media and the events related to them are
|
||
still present in the consciousness of the Sudanese.[^89] Most of the
|
||
murals have been painted over by the police, but the ones in the
|
||
University of Khartoum campus have remained untouched. They were
|
||
protected from destruction by the people and can also be seen in
|
||
galleries online.[^90] These murals are examples of the strong emotions
|
||
evoked in the Sudanese people, even after the end of the revolution.
|
||
Their preservation can be understood as a tool for remembering, for
|
||
commemorating the loss of loved ones and the tragedies of many families,
|
||
raising people\'s spirits, and keeping resistance alive.
|
||
|
||
The artwork that was created out of this revolution has a significant
|
||
role in civil disobedience. Sudanese people lived under constant
|
||
control, repression, and racism-based politics. The need to talk about
|
||
it loudly and be heard was unbearable. Art helped them express
|
||
themselves and brought people together for a common cause. It also
|
||
changed the information flow and created a dialogue with the government.
|
||
The protesters\' actions inspired the artists who, over time, mobilized
|
||
the people. It was a mutually reinforcing relationship that gave birth
|
||
to a freedom movement that emanated strength and bravery. Art became an
|
||
integral part of this movement as the artists raised awareness and
|
||
became a voice of the people. Art was inclusive, anti-conformist, and
|
||
empowering, and it was used as a censorship-free source of news and
|
||
expression.
|
||
|
||
Street art and graffiti glorify people and their sacrifice, challenge
|
||
them during the revolution and after, and remain a constant memento of
|
||
the events in Sudan. War has many faces, but whether it is a cultural,
|
||
ideological, or religious war, it is associated with social change and
|
||
never leaves the country unchanged. In Sudan, during the uprising, this
|
||
change took place in the freedom of expression, greater self-awareness
|
||
of citizens and creativity in all areas of fine arts. Poetry, songs,
|
||
photography, collages, and street and online art during the revolution
|
||
in the blink of an eye responded to the ever-changing situation in
|
||
Sudan. Art inspired by actual events evokes instant connection and
|
||
understanding between the artist and the viewer. Apart from
|
||
anti-government slogans, art reflects the revolutionary reality. It
|
||
shows sadness and fear; there are visible references to police
|
||
brutality, excessive use of force, tear gas, ammunition, torture, and
|
||
mental and physical exhaustion of people. It is an incredibly moving
|
||
picture, without glorifying a peaceful uprising but considering the
|
||
dangers associated with it. Devoid of the romantic vision of the freedom
|
||
struggle in which all protesters happily return home.
|
||
|
||
The events in Sudan inspired and still inspire artists. 'Kejer's Prison'
|
||
-- a short film by Mohamed Kordofani, in a moving way shows the social
|
||
tear during the revolution, especially among the military soldiers.[^91]
|
||
Many years of indoctrination or compulsion to obey the order have caused
|
||
the soldiers to turn against their fellow citizens. Everyone should be
|
||
held accountable, there is no doubt, but Mohamed Kordofan's film changes
|
||
a bit our perspective on the events. We want to hear their stories and
|
||
find out how they became torturers for those they should protect.
|
||
Abu'Obayda Mohamed, known as OXDA, in his graphic shows the burning
|
||
Khartoum, where the militia's attack on the sit-in on 3 June 2019 took
|
||
place (Figure 47). The graphic was created a year later with a
|
||
dedication to all the fallen and the shed blood on the dangerous road to
|
||
democracy. Also, in 2021, the anniversary of the June 3 massacre was
|
||
celebrated, emphasizing that the memory of these events is still alive,
|
||
and the victims of the regime's violence will not be forgotten.
|
||
|
||
Even after the revolution, the role of the artists has not changed. On
|
||
the contrary, the artists have gained more momentum, and they are using
|
||
the newly acquired freedom. However, social and political change is a
|
||
long process, and Sudan\'s future remains unknown. The economy is
|
||
suffering from inflation and the continued devaluation of the Sudanese
|
||
pound. The locust plague and the flood disaster hit agricultural
|
||
production, and the COVID-19 pandemic has exacerbated the health crisis
|
||
in the country. All this contributed to the deepening of the recession
|
||
in 2020 and 2021. On the other hand, the U.S. removed Sudan from the
|
||
list of states assisting terrorism and mediated the signing of a peace
|
||
agreement with Israel, after which Sudan received \$ 1 billion in
|
||
financial aid. The situation in Sudan will not change dramatically
|
||
overnight, however, the government has proposed fuel subsidies and tax
|
||
law reforms, as well as social protection programs. New fiscal and
|
||
monetary policies were introduced while renewing diplomatic relations
|
||
and attempts to stabilize the economic situation. Sudan is ready for
|
||
fundamental economic and institutional reforms and the first changes
|
||
have already been noticed in August 2021, when the inflation decreased
|
||
by 35 points. International media were talking about stabilization in
|
||
the country.
|
||
|
||
**2022 update. The conflict in Sudan is not over.**
|
||
|
||
In October 2021 the Sudanese army carried out a coup against the
|
||
civilian leadership. Prime Minister Adballa Hamdook and his cabinet were
|
||
arrested. Strikes broke out again and the actions of the army were
|
||
condemned. This situation provoked a reaction from the international
|
||
financial institutions supporting Sudan and forced the cessation of
|
||
financial aid totaling \$4.6bn. Furthermore, \$700m of financial aid
|
||
from the US has been blocked, along with the supply of grain to be used
|
||
in subsidizing bread.[^92] The cost of living began to rise
|
||
dramatically, and inflation soared.
|
||
|
||
The Sudanese still protest against the military coup on a weekly basis.
|
||
Currently carried out by professional groups, students, and women\'s
|
||
rights groups. Protests still rely on non-violent tactics and the use of
|
||
social media is still crucial for wider media coverage. The rise of
|
||
local activism in Sudan is a phenomenon that continues to grow and reach
|
||
even larger circles. Protests re-emerged and Sudanese people demand a
|
||
constitution and a democratically elected government.
|
||
|
||
**Bibliography**
|
||
|
||
ABDEL AZIZ, Azza Ahmed. *The Third Sudanese Revolution Reinstates Women
|
||
from All Walks of Life onto the Map of Sudanese Public Life.*
|
||
https://noria-research.com/the-third-sudanese-revolution-reinstates-women/.
|
||
|
||
AFRICA NEWS. *Sudan Protest Hub: Anti-Bashir Protesters Tear Gassed in
|
||
Omdurman*, Africanews, January 2, 2019.
|
||
https://www.africanews.com/2019/02/01/police-clashes-with-sudanese-protesting-a-state-of-emergency-in-atbara/.
|
||
|
||
ANONYMOUS. *We Are Fed up! The Power of a New Generation of Sudanese
|
||
Youth Activists.*
|
||
https://www.opendemocracy.net/en/5050/we-are-fed-up-power-of-new-generation-of-sudanese-youth-activists/.
|
||
|
||
BERRIDGE, W. J. *Civil Uprisings in Modern Sudan: The 'Khartoum Springs'
|
||
of 1964 and 1985.* A modern history of politics and violence. London:
|
||
Bloomsbury Academic An imprint of Bloomsbury Publishing Plc, 2015.
|
||
|
||
BIOR, Ayen. *Sudan's Social Media Deemed Major Player in Bashir's
|
||
Ouster.*
|
||
https://www.voanews.com/archive/sudans-social-media-deemed-major-player-bashirs-ouster.
|
||
|
||
BISHAI, Linda & ELSHAMI, Azaz. *"We Are All Darfur!" -- Sudan's Unity
|
||
Protests Stand a Real Chance. Time for the West to Step up*.
|
||
https://www.justsecurity.org/62404/we-darfur-sudans-unity-protests-stand-real-chance-time-west-step-up/.
|
||
|
||
BOLATITO, Aina-Obe Shamsuddin. *Sudan Revolution: An Exploration Causes
|
||
and Consequences for Power Struggle and Regime Change*, 2019.
|
||
https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.3502891.
|
||
|
||
BROWN, Marie Grace. *History Stands Alongside the Woman in the White
|
||
Tobe*.
|
||
https://stanfordpress.typepad.com/blog/2019/05/history-stands-alongside-the-woman-in-the-white-tobe.html.
|
||
|
||
CAPRON, Alexandre. *In Sudan, Empty Tear Gas Canisters from Protests
|
||
Turned into Art*. The Observers - France 24, January 17, 2019.
|
||
https://observers.france24.com/en/20190117-sudan-tear-gas-protests-art.
|
||
|
||
CARMICHAEL, Flora & PINNELL, Owen. *How Fake News from Sudan's Regime
|
||
Backfired*. *BBC News*, April 25, 2019.
|
||
https://www.bbc.com/news/blogs-trending-47899076.
|
||
|
||
CASCIARRI, Barbara & MANFREDI, Stefano. *Freedom, Peace and Justice - a
|
||
Glossary of the Third Sudanese Revolution :* حرية سلام وعدالة
|
||
|
||
CIPESA, Collaboration on International ICT Policy for East and Southern
|
||
Africa, *Sudan's Bad Laws, Internet Censorship and Repressed Civil
|
||
Liberities. https//cipesa.org*
|
||
|
||
DESHAYES, Clément & ETTIENNE, Margaux & MEDANI, Khadidja. *Reflection on
|
||
the Sudanese Revolutionary Dynamics*. Middle East & North Africa
|
||
Program.
|
||
https://noria-research.com/special-issue-on-sudan-down-with-the-government-of-thieves/.
|
||
|
||
COPNALL, James. *A Poisonous Thorn in Our Hearts: Sudan and South
|
||
Sudan's Bitter and Incomplete Divorce*. London: Hurst & Company, 2014.
|
||
|
||
DABANGA, Radio. *Prosecution Denounces Call to Revive Sudan's Repealed
|
||
Public Order Law.*
|
||
https://www.dabangasudan.org/en/all-news/article/public-prosecution-denounces-call-to-revive-sudan-s-repealed-public-order-law.
|
||
|
||
DAHIR, Abdi Latif. *Sudan's Protests Inspire Art, Graffiti Revolution*.
|
||
*Quartz*, December 7, 2019.
|
||
https://qz.com/africa/1664733/sudans-protests-inspire-art-graffiti-revolution/.
|
||
|
||
DIAB, Ola. *Everything You Need to Know About the Sudan Revolution.*
|
||
http://500wordsmag.com/sudan-news/everything-you-need-to-know-about-the-sudan-revolution/.
|
||
|
||
EDITORS. *Cartooning for Peace*"
|
||
https://www.cartooningforpeace.org/en/editos/sudan-the-iconic-womens-revolution/.
|
||
|
||
ELAMIN, Nisrin & ISMAIL, Tahani. *The Many Mothers of Sudan's
|
||
Revolution*" *Al Jazeera*, April 5, 2019.
|
||
https://www.aljazeera.com/opinions/2019/5/4/the-many-mothers-of-sudans-revolution/.
|
||
|
||
ELHASSAN, Sara. *How Sudanese Art Is Fueling the Revolution*"
|
||
*OkayAfrica*, February 21, 2019.
|
||
https://www.okayafrica.com/young-sudanese-art-is-fueling-the-protest-revolution/.
|
||
|
||
---------. *Sudan's revolution Isn't a Fluke; It's Tradition*"
|
||
*OkayAfrica*, June 14, 2019.
|
||
https://www.okayafrica.com/sudans-revolution-isnt-a-fluke-its-tradition/.
|
||
|
||
---------. *Inside Sudan's Viral Revolution: What You Need to Know*"
|
||
*OkayAfrica*, June 21, 2019.
|
||
https://www.okayafrica.com/inside-sudans-viral-revolution-what-you-need-to-know/.
|
||
|
||
FUHRMANN, Larissa-Diana. *#sudanrevolts: Contesting Power & Violence
|
||
Through Art*.
|
||
|
||
https://shado-mag.com/opinion/sudanrevolts-contesting-power-violence-through-art/.
|
||
|
||
GAAFAR Reem, SHAKWAT, Omnia. *Sudanese Women at the Heart of the
|
||
Revolution: African Feminism (AF)*"
|
||
https://africanfeminism.com/sudanese-women-at-the-heart-the-revolution/.
|
||
|
||
HÄGGSTRÖM, Issraa Elkogali. *Art for the Revolution: How Artists Have
|
||
Changed the Protests in Sudan.*
|
||
https://kultwatch.se/2019/04/02/art-for-the-revolution-how-artists-have-become-key-for-the-protests-in-sudan/.
|
||
|
||
HASHIM, Mohanad. *In Pictures: The Art Fuelling Sudan's Revolution.*
|
||
*BBC News*, May 5, 2019. https://www.bbc.com/news/world-africa-48126363.
|
||
|
||
HASSAB, Afnan. *Sudan Uprising: On an Artistic Note.*
|
||
https://500wordsmag.com/art-and-culture/sudan-uprising-on-an-artistic-note/.
|
||
|
||
HASSAN, Mai & KODOUDA, Ahmed. *Sudan's Uprising: The Fall of a Dictator*
|
||
|
||
*http://journalofdemocracy.org/articles/sudan-uprising-the-fall-of-a-dicator/*
|
||
|
||
HENDAWI, Hamza. *Sudan: An Artist's Tribute to Women Leaders of the
|
||
Pro-Democracy Movement*. *The National*, January 19, 2020.
|
||
https://www.thenationalnews.com/world/africa/sudan-an-artist-s-tribute-to-women-leaders-of-the-pro-democracy-movement-1.966191.
|
||
|
||
HUMAN RIGHTS WATCH. *"They Were Shouting 'Kill Them'*".
|
||
https://www.hrw.org/report/2019/11/18/they-were-shouting-kill-them/sudans-violent-crackdown-protesters-khartoum.
|
||
|
||
IDRIS, Amir H. *Conflict and Politics of Identity in Sudan*. Boston
|
||
Mass.: Palgrave Macmillan, 2005.
|
||
|
||
\*AKWEI, Ismail. *Sudan's Protests Through Cartoons, the Daring Work of
|
||
Boushra Cartoonist*.
|
||
https://face2faceafrica.com/article/documenting-sudans-protests-through-cartoons-the-daring-work-of-boushra-cartoonist.
|
||
|
||
KAMABRESSI, Farouck. To save its economy, Sudan needs civilian rule. Al
|
||
Jazeera, 2022.
|
||
|
||
https://www.aljazeera.com/amp/opinions./2022/10/25/to-save-its-economy-sudan-needs-civilian-rule
|
||
|
||
KARAR, Haytham. *Protesters Dismantling Modus Operandi of Sudan's
|
||
Oppressor*. https://sudantribune.com/spip.php?article67038.
|
||
|
||
KORDOFANI, Mohamed. *\"Kejer\'s Prison\" - Short Film* سجن الكجر - فلم
|
||
قصير." https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Enyax1Dzj_g.
|
||
|
||
KUWAIT TIMES. *Bashir's Overthrow Inspires Sudan Graffiti Artists*.
|
||
Kuwait Times.
|
||
https://news.kuwaittimes.net/website/bashirs-overthrow-inspires-sudan-graffiti-artists/.
|
||
|
||
LAMENSCH, Marie. *Sudan's Artists of the Revolution: An Interview with
|
||
Alaa Satir*. Revolution.
|
||
https://www.themantle.com/arts-and-culture/sudans-artists-revolution-1.
|
||
|
||
---------. *Sudan's Artists of the Revolution: An Interview with Assil
|
||
Diab*.
|
||
|
||
---------. *Sudan's Artists of the Revolution: An Interview with Mounir
|
||
Khalil.*
|
||
https://www.themantle.com/arts-and-culture/sudans-artists-revolution-2.
|
||
|
||
LATIF, Dena. *"You Arrogant Racist, We Are All Darfur"; Human Rights
|
||
Protests as Nation-Building in Sudan."* Human Rights Studies Master of
|
||
Arts Program, Columbia University.
|
||
|
||
LICHTENSTEIN, Amanda. *Read the Scent of Revolution: The Story Behind
|
||
Sudan's Legendary Perfume Label Remix.*
|
||
https://www.scribd.com/article/406480542/The-Scent-Of-Revolution-The-Story-Behind-Sudan-s-Legendary-Perfume-Label-Remix.
|
||
|
||
MURRAY, Elizabeth. *How Art Helped Propel Sudan's Revolution.*
|
||
https://www.usip.org/blog/2020/11/how-art-helped-propel-sudans-revolution.
|
||
|
||
NORBROOK, Nicholas. *Sudan: Who Is Hemeti, the Butcher of the
|
||
Revolution?* The Africa Report, May 6, 2019.
|
||
https://www.theafricareport.com/13665/sudan-who-is-hemeti-the-butcher-of-the-revolution/.
|
||
|
||
OSMAN, Muhammed & BEARAK, Max. *Omar Al-Bashir Exploited Sudan's Ethnic
|
||
Division for Decades. Now Sudan Is United Against Him*. The Washington
|
||
Post, January 19, 2019.
|
||
https://www.washingtonpost.com/world/omar-al-bashir-exploited-sudans-ethnic-division-for-decades-now-sudan-is-united-against-him/2019/01/19/a7b5d0a0-1851-11e9-b8e6-567190c2fd08_story.html?noredirect=on.
|
||
|
||
POWELL, Brian. *Sudan Constitutional Declaration: Draft Constitutional
|
||
Charter for the 2019 Transitional Period*.
|
||
|
||
REILLY, Katie. *The Iconic Photo of Her Helped Fuel Sudan's Revolution.
|
||
Now, She and Other Women Are Being Sidelined.* Time, October 30, 2019.
|
||
https://time.com/5712952/alaa-salah-sudan-women-protest/.
|
||
|
||
ROBATHAN, Hannah & PEARCE, Isabella. *The Satir Sisters: Two Artists
|
||
Inspiring Change Through Illustration.*
|
||
https://shado-mag.com/do/the-satir-sisters-two-artists-inspiring-change-through-illustration/.
|
||
|
||
SALIH, Zeinab Mohammed & WILSON Tom. *Sudanese Women Take Lead in
|
||
Protests Against Bashir.* Financial Times*,* March 28, 2019.
|
||
https://www.ft.com/content/8e185568-4976-11e9-bbc9-6917dce3dc62
|
||
|
||
Shirin Jaafari. "Here's the Story Behind the Iconic Image of the
|
||
Sudanese Woman in White."
|
||
https://www.pri.org/stories/2019-04-10/heres-story-behind-iconic-image-sudanese-woman-white.
|
||
|
||
SIHA NETWORK. *Criminalization of Women in Sudan. A Need for Fundamental
|
||
Reform*. Strategic Initiative for Women in the Horn of Africa and The
|
||
Redress Trust.
|
||
|
||
STAFF WRITER. *Sudan Just Criminalized Female Genital Mutilation in a
|
||
Landmark Victory for Women.* Scene Arabia*.*
|
||
https://scenearabia.com/Life/Sudan-Just-Criminalised-Female-Genital-Mutilation-in-a-Landmark-Victory-for-Women.
|
||
|
||
ROYCHOUDHURY, Supriya. *The Art of Resistance: When Imagination Meets
|
||
Technology at Protests from India to Chile*. Scroll.in, March 14, 2020.
|
||
https://scroll.in/article/954091/the-art-of-resistance-when-imagination-meets-technology-at-protests-from-india-to-chile.
|
||
|
||
THE OBSERVATEURS. *Brothers Create Mosaic Portraits of Protesters Killed
|
||
in Sudan's Revolution.* Yahoo Finance, March 12, 2019.
|
||
https://uk.finance.yahoo.com/news/brothers-create-mosaic-portraits-protesters-154135130.html?guccounter=1&guce_referrer=aHR0cHM6Ly93d3cuZ29vZ2xlLmNvbS8&guce_referrer_sig=AQAAAHL-VQ5xkU91oZq4s1TD6QLgcV61MXYnj6rZspRnJ8qHlz-gvCl52tx2qFlnKAb2Nbn2nyIyUg_hb9iZkbBs6r9FI_KEYHGTH034INGwx8IOF4neA0Mw_Yu6hT-WyMiHQAOg_39XhP-gg7wD3MnoyTcY11BnhMMffy4o6N4IAxaH.
|
||
|
||
UK HOME OFFICE. *Sudan Opposition to the Government, Including Sur Place
|
||
Activity: (November 2018)*. 2018.
|
||
|
||
WILDE BOTTA, Emma. *The Revolution Has Emerged: Sudan's Acute
|
||
Contradictions.*
|
||
https://roape.net/2019/09/05/the-revolution-has-emerged-sudans-acute-contradictions/.
|
||
|
||
[^1]: BERRIDGE, *Civil Uprising in Modern Sudan, pp. 13-34.*
|
||
|
||
[^2]: DESHAYES & ETIENNE & MEDANI*, Reflection on the Sudanese
|
||
Revolutionary Dynamics*.
|
||
|
||
[^3]: BOTALITO, *Sudan Revolution: An Exploration Causes and
|
||
Consequences for Power Struggle and Regime Change.*
|
||
|
||
[^4]: In 1964, the so-called \'Southern Problem\' became the cause of
|
||
the conflict. The increasing discrimination against the Christian
|
||
South of Sudan was the result of the policy of Abbud's regime. A
|
||
\'Southern problem\' became widely discussed at the time, which led
|
||
to clashes between students and the police at the University of
|
||
Khartoum. A very important factor depending on the conflict was the
|
||
government\'s ineffective economic policy and the rising costs of
|
||
living. Eventually, the protests led to the president\'s
|
||
resignation.
|
||
|
||
[^5]: Any newspaper under this law could be suspended without any court
|
||
order and its employees arrested.
|
||
|
||
[^6]: CIPESA, *Sudan's Bad Laws, Internet Censorship and Repressed Civil
|
||
Liberties.*
|
||
|
||
[^7]: For more information see: *Sudan: Press freedom still in
|
||
transition a year after Omar al-Bashir's removal*, Reporters Without
|
||
Borders, 2020.
|
||
|
||
[^8]: WILDE BOTTA, *The Revolution Has Emerged: Sudan's Acute
|
||
Contradictions*.
|
||
|
||
[^9]: COPNALL, *A Poisonous Thorn in Our Hearts*: *Sudan and South
|
||
Sudan\'s Bitter and Incomplete Divorce.*
|
||
|
||
[^10]: https://www.instagram.com/p/BtBLM5cFNG-/
|
||
|
||
[^11]: KARAR, *Protesters Dismantling Modus Operandi of Sudan\'s
|
||
Oppressor*: *"...the International Monetary Fund (IMF), the
|
||
government adopted austerity measures that resulted in cutting fuel
|
||
and bread subsidies. However, the adjustment plan has immensely hit
|
||
the extremely poor, estimated to be around 36.1 per cent of the
|
||
population. In December 2018, the inflation rate has risen to 72.94
|
||
per cent, the second worst rate worldwide after Venezuela*."
|
||
|
||
[^12]: ELHASSAN, How Sudanese Art Is Fueling the Revolution.
|
||
|
||
[^13]: BERRIDGE, Civil Uprisings in Modern Sudan: The \'Khartoum
|
||
Springs\' of 1964 and 1985.
|
||
|
||
[^14]: ELHASSAN, Sudan's Revolution Isn\'t a Fluke, It\'s Tradition.
|
||
|
||
[^15]: Ibid.
|
||
|
||
[^16]: LAMENSCH, Sudan\'s Artists of the Revolution: An Interview with
|
||
Mounir Khalil.
|
||
|
||
[^17]: MURRAY, How Art Helped Propel Sudan's Revolution.
|
||
|
||
[^18]: AFRICA NEWS, Sudan Protest Hub: Anti-Bashir Protesters Tear
|
||
Gassed in Omdurman.
|
||
|
||
[^19]: HASSAN and KODOUDA, *Sudan's Uprising: The Fall of a Dictator,*
|
||
pp.97-100.
|
||
|
||
[^20]: [HÄGGSTRÖM](https://www.kasperhaggstrom.com/) , Art for the
|
||
Revolution: How Artists Have Changed the Protests in Sudan.
|
||
|
||
[^21]: NORBROOK, *Sudan: Who Is Hemeti, the Butcher of the Revolution?*
|
||
|
||
[^22]: BOTTA, *The Revolution has Emerged: Sudan's Acute
|
||
Contradictions*.
|
||
|
||
[^23]: HUMAN RIGHTS WATCH, *"They Were Shouting 'Kill Them'"*.
|
||
|
||
[^24]: POWELL, *Sudan Constitutional Declaration: Draft Constitutional
|
||
Charter for the 2019 Transitional Period*.
|
||
|
||
[^25]: Policy and military attacked sleeping protesters and destroy the
|
||
site of the sit-in. People were shot and wounded by machetes and
|
||
their bodies were thrown into the River Nile. For more information
|
||
see: \"*Chaos and Fire": An Analysis of Sudan\'s June 3, 2019,
|
||
Khartoum Massacre*, Physician for Human Rights.
|
||
|
||
Videos made by protesters during the massacre (contains disturbing
|
||
scenes): htpp://bbc.com/news/av/worls-africa-48956133
|
||
|
||
[^26]: The Public Order Law was proposed in 1989 and created as a set of
|
||
legal provisions from the Sudanese Criminal Law Act. A restrictive
|
||
public law that controlled how women acted and dressed in public,
|
||
violating their privacy and freedoms. Promotes discrimination
|
||
against women and limits their social activities. For more
|
||
information see: http://democracyfirstgroup.org
|
||
|
||
[^27]: DABANGA, *Prosecution Denounces Call to Revive Sudan's Repealed
|
||
Public Order Law*.
|
||
|
||
[^28]: STAFF WRITER, *Sudan Just Criminalised Female Genital Mutilation
|
||
in a Landmark Victory for Women*. Cartoon by Alaa Satir condemning
|
||
FGM with a sign: female body cannot be edited, available:
|
||
https://www.instagram.com/p/BjHpwZjFxD9/
|
||
|
||
[^29]: BOTTA, *The Revolution.*
|
||
|
||
[^30]: Propaganda is not in the scope of this article, for more
|
||
information on this matter see: GOLDSTEIN, *Exploiting Darfur
|
||
Genocide for Propaganda*, Sudan Tribune, 2006.
|
||
|
||
[^31]: OSMAN & BEARAK, *Omar Al-Bashir Exploited Sudan's Ethnic Division
|
||
for Decades. Now Sudan Is United Against Him*.
|
||
|
||
[^32]: BOTALITO, *Sudan Revolution.*
|
||
|
||
[^33]: LATIF, *You Arrogant Racist, We are All Darfur'; Human Rights
|
||
Protests as Nation-Building in Sudan,* pp. 54 - 67.
|
||
|
||
[^34]: IDRIS, *Conflict and Politics of Identity in Sudan.*
|
||
|
||
[^35]: CARMICHAEL & PINNELL, *How Fake News from Sudan's Regime
|
||
Backfired*.
|
||
|
||
[^36]: BISHAI & ELSHAMI, *"We Are All Darfur!" -- Sudan's Unity Protests
|
||
Stand a Real Chance. Time for the West to Step up*.
|
||
|
||
[^37]: HASHIM, *In Pictures: The Art Fuelling Sudan\'s Revolution*.
|
||
|
||
[^38]: For more information see: REEVES. BENJAMIN, *Online fake news and
|
||
hate speech are fuelling tribal 'genocide' in South Sudan*,
|
||
http://theworld.org
|
||
|
||
[^39]: For more information see: Global Gender Gap Report.
|
||
|
||
[^40]: SIHA NETWORK, *Criminalisation of women in Sudan. A need for
|
||
Fundamental Reform,* pp. 8-13, 41-43.
|
||
|
||
[^41]: SALIH & WILSON, *Sudanese Women Take Lead in Protests Against
|
||
Bashir*.
|
||
|
||
[^42]: HENDAWI, *Sudan: An Artist's Tribute to Women Leaders of the
|
||
Pro-Democracy Movement*.
|
||
|
||
[^43]: For more information see: SALIH, Zeinab Mohammed, '*I was raised
|
||
to love our home': Sudan's singing protester speaks up*, The
|
||
Guardian, April 10, 20919; REILLY, Katie, *The Iconic Photo of Her
|
||
Helped Fuel Sudan's Revolution. Now, She and Other Women Are Being
|
||
Sidelined*, The Times, October 30, 2019.
|
||
|
||
[^44]: JAAFARI, *Here\'s the Story Behind the Iconic Image of the
|
||
Sudanese Woman in White*.
|
||
|
||
[^45]: BROWN, *History Stands Alongside the Woman in the White Tobe*.
|
||
|
||
[^46]: ELAMIN & ISMAIL, *The Many Mothers of Sudan's Revolution*.
|
||
|
||
[^47]: REILLY, *The Iconic Photo of Her Helped Fuel Sudan\'s Revolution.
|
||
Now, She and Other Women Are Being Sidelined.*
|
||
|
||
[^48]:
|
||
## LICHTENSTEIN, *Read the Scent of Revolution: The Story Behind Sudan\'s Legendary Perfume Label Remi .* Exhibition Amado Alfadni work at the Sulger-Buel Gallery in London: https://thezay.org/amado-alfadni-kendakas-and-bint-al-sudan/
|
||
|
||
[^49]: ABDEL AZIZ, *The Third Sudanese Revolution Reinstates Women from
|
||
All Walks of Life onto the Map of Sudanese Public Life*.
|
||
|
||
[^50]: KUWAIT TIMES, *Bashir\'s Overthrow Inspires Sudan Graffiti
|
||
Artists*.
|
||
|
||
[^51]: https://www.instagram.com/p/Bqm6Ne1lxrP/
|
||
|
||
[^52]: HÄGGSTRÖM, *Art for the Revolution.*
|
||
|
||
[^53]: DAHIR, *Sudan's Protests Inspire Art, Graffiti Revolution*.
|
||
|
||
[^54]: For more information see: MONDESIRE. Zachary, *Race after
|
||
Revolution: Imagining Blackness and Africanity in the "New Sudan"*,
|
||
Middle East Political Science, 2020.
|
||
|
||
[^55]: LAMENSCH, Sudan\'s Artists.
|
||
|
||
[^56]: HÄGGSTRÖM, *Art for the Revolution.*
|
||
|
||
[^57]: THE OBSERVATEURS, *Brothers Create Mosaic Portraits of Protesters
|
||
Killed in Sudan's Revolution*.
|
||
|
||
[^58]: ANONYMOUS, *We Are Fed up! The Power of a New Generation of
|
||
Sudanese Youth Activists*.
|
||
|
||
[^59]: UK HOME OFFICE, *Sudan Opposition to the Government, Including
|
||
Sur Place Activity: (November 2018).*
|
||
|
||
[^60]: For more information about the structure and evolution of the
|
||
Sudanese professionals Association see:
|
||
https://www.arab-reform.net/publication/sudanese-professionals-association-structure-evolutioroles-and-coalitions-changes-and-future-prospects/
|
||
|
||
[^61]: BIOR, *Sudan\'s Social Media Deemed Major Player in Bashir\'s
|
||
Ouster*.
|
||
|
||
[^62]: HASSAB, *Sudan Uprising: On an Artistic Note*.
|
||
|
||
[^63]: https://www.bbc.com/news/av/world-africa-48956133
|
||
|
||
[^64]: ROBATHAN & PEARCE, *The Satir Sisters: Two Artists Inspiring
|
||
Change Through Illustration*.
|
||
|
||
[^65]: ELHASSAN, *Inside Sudan\'s Viral Revolution: What You Need to
|
||
Know*.
|
||
|
||
[^66]: GAAFAR & SHAKWAT, *Sudanese Women at the Heart of the Revolution:
|
||
African Feminism (AF)*.
|
||
|
||
[^67]: https://www.worldpressphoto.org/collection/photo/2020/39605/1/Yasuyoshi-Chiba
|
||
|
||
[^68]: FUHRMANN, *#sudanrevolts: Contesting Power & Violence Through
|
||
Art*.
|
||
|
||
[^69]: https://www.dabangasudan.org/en/all-news/article/public-anger-in-sudan-capital-as-children-crushed-by-niss-driver
|
||
|
||
[^70]: FUHRMANN, *#sudanrevolts.*
|
||
|
||
[^71]: HASSAB, *Sudan Uprising.*
|
||
|
||
[^72]: CASCIARRI & MANFREDI, *Freedom, Peace and Justice - a Glossary of
|
||
the Third Sudanese Revolution, p.18.*
|
||
|
||
[^73]: DIAB, *Everything You Need to Know About the Sudan Revolution*.
|
||
|
||
[^74]: EDITORS, *Cartooning for Peace*.
|
||
|
||
[^75]: AKWEI, *Sudan's Protests Through Cartoons, the Daring Work of
|
||
Boushra Cartoonist.*
|
||
|
||
[^76]: FUHRMANN, *#sudanrevolts.*
|
||
|
||
[^77]: https://twitter.com/Merg_Salih/status/1401508418708545540
|
||
|
||
[^78]: CASCIARRI & MANFREDI, *Freedom, pp. 15-17*.
|
||
|
||
[^79]: DESHAYES & ETIENNE & MEDANI*, Reflection.*
|
||
|
||
[^80]: HASHIM, *In pictures: The art fuelling Sudan\'s revolution*.
|
||
|
||
[^81]: FUHRMANN, *#sudanrevolts*.
|
||
|
||
[^82]: ROYCHOUDHURY, *The Art of Resistance: When Imagination Meets
|
||
Technology at Protests from India to Chile*.
|
||
|
||
[^83]: LAMENSCH, *Sudan\'s Artists of the Revolution: An Interview with
|
||
Assil Diab*.
|
||
|
||
[^84]: For more information see: ERIC REEVES, *On the Brutal Murder of
|
||
Ahmed al-Khair of Kashm al-Qirba, February 2, 2019.
|
||
<https://sudanreeves.org/2019/02/02/on-the-brutal-murder-of-ahmed-al-khair-of-khashm-al-qirba-february-2-2019/>.*
|
||
Authors note: Some readers may find the description of events
|
||
distressing.
|
||
|
||
[^85]: CARMICHAEL & PINNELL, *How fake news from Sudan's regime
|
||
backfired.*
|
||
|
||
[^86]: MURRAY, *How Art Helped Propel Sudan's Revolution*.
|
||
|
||
[^87]: ROYCHOUDHURY, *The Art of Resistance.*
|
||
|
||
[^88]: CAPRON, *In Sudan, Empty Tear Gas Canisters from Protests Turned
|
||
into Art*.
|
||
|
||
[^89]: The art of the Sudanese revolution was exhibited at the
|
||
University of London and Khartoum
|
||
|
||
[^90]: http://sudanrevolutionart.org
|
||
|
||
[^91]: KORDOFANI, *"Kejer\'s Prison - Short Film* سجن الكجر - فلم قصير,"
|
||
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Enyax1Dzj_g.
|
||
|
||
[^92]: KAMABRESSI, *To save its economy, Sudan needs civilian rule.*
|