punctu
This commit is contained in:
parent
75d6b2b20c
commit
532b253133
1 changed files with 8 additions and 8 deletions
|
@ -10,7 +10,7 @@ keywords: ["Book review", "MDASP", "Fourth Cataract", "Derek Welsby", "Sudan", "
|
|||
The volume at hand is, as stated in its summary (pp. xxx-xxxi), "the
|
||||
first of several which will present in detail the results of the research
|
||||
undertaken by the Sudan Archaeological Research Society (SARS) as a part
|
||||
of the Merowe Dam Archaeological Salvage Project (MDASP)". By this
|
||||
of the Merowe Dam Archaeological Salvage Project (MDASP)." By this
|
||||
statement alone, one should welcome most warmly this publication, since
|
||||
it is launching a series of volumes that will make public the immense
|
||||
data collected during the MDASP since the completion of the project in
|
||||
|
@ -101,8 +101,8 @@ Robert Bussert, and Ronny Schomacker describe "The landscape of the
|
|||
Fourth Nile Cataract and its geomorphologic evolution" (pp. 15--45);
|
||||
while Arnaud Malterer provides a summary of the master thesis that he
|
||||
wrote in Chapter 3 titled "Merowe Dam Project. Land use and Vegetation
|
||||
in the Flooding Area of a planned Hydrodam in Northern Sudan" (pp. 46--
|
||||
78). Both chapters are very rich in information and set in place the
|
||||
in the Flooding Area of a planned Hydrodam in Northern Sudan" (pp. 46--78).
|
||||
Both chapters are very rich in information and set in place the
|
||||
environment upon which humans developed the cultures that were hosted in
|
||||
the Fourth Cataract of the Nile region. The scientific accuracy of the
|
||||
descriptions is impressive in both chapters. There is, however, a
|
||||
|
@ -116,11 +116,11 @@ Wolf et al's contribution, but it raises a question as to the target
|
|||
readership of such a publication. If this should be decided on the basis
|
||||
of Chapter 2, then the record is to be kept for those that in the future
|
||||
will need it for further studies on relevant fields; it acts as metadata
|
||||
to an archive. But is it necessary in the 21^st^ century with the
|
||||
to an archive. But is it necessary in the 21st century with the
|
||||
immensity of digital solutions to choose the vector of a printed book
|
||||
for such a task? One must not lose sight that a variety of readers,
|
||||
including (primarily?) those English-speaking deracinated locals, long
|
||||
for a such a "book" to remember their "paradise lost". Conversely, the
|
||||
for a such a "book" to remember their "paradise lost." Conversely, the
|
||||
goal of such publications may simply be to make data available to the
|
||||
specialized public, and not to create synthetic, edited overviews of
|
||||
topics based on the data accumulated by the researchers and interpreted
|
||||
|
@ -129,11 +129,11 @@ by the given author(s) and editor(s) so as to be interesting for a wider
|
|||
expectation after the 15 years that it took from the end of the MDASP
|
||||
project to the publication of the volume. The present reviewer feels
|
||||
that the editor of the volume *did not have the time* to choose the
|
||||
second option but wanted this first volume "out". The contributors had to
|
||||
second option but wanted this first volume "out." The contributors had to
|
||||
submit their work within the publication's deadlines; this time pressure
|
||||
is felt elsewhere in the volume too, primarily in the many typographic
|
||||
mistakes and some unnecessary contradictions. The most striking example
|
||||
of the latter is that Volume VI on "The rock art and rock gongs", which
|
||||
of the latter is that Volume VI on "The rock art and rock gongs," which
|
||||
was announced in p. xxx in the Summary of the volume, is not included in
|
||||
the description of the SARS' publication of the project in p. 12.
|
||||
|
||||
|
@ -247,7 +247,7 @@ among the inhabitants of the villages she visited.
|
|||
|
||||
Finally, chapter 8 by Frances Welsh is about "Architecture and life in
|
||||
villages of the Fourth Nile Cataract in the region of al Tiref"
|
||||
(pp.190--238). This chapter is a continuation of Reshetnikova's in terms
|
||||
(pp. 190--238). This chapter is a continuation of Reshetnikova's in terms
|
||||
of the geography it covers moving upstream from Dar el-Arab, while it
|
||||
functions in a complementary manner since Welsh also exhaustively
|
||||
presents the different types of buildings, their function in the
|
||||
|
|
Loading…
Add table
Reference in a new issue