diff --git a/content/article/sadeq.md b/content/article/sadeq.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..067b4bd --- /dev/null +++ b/content/article/sadeq.md @@ -0,0 +1,647 @@ +--- +title: "My Grandparents\' House: A Sociological Perspective" +authors: ["abdelsadeq.md"] +abstract: +keywords: ["Nubia", "resettlement", "architecture"] +--- + +**Introduction** + +For more than fifteen centuries, Nubians lived in the Nile Valley +between the First Cataract at Aswan in southern Egypt and the Fourth +Cataract at Dongola in Sudan. The cataract at Aswan, and the barren +deserts on either side of the valley isolated Nubians from other +neighboring groups, enabling them to retain their cohesiveness as an +ethno-linguistic group with distinguishing cultural traditions. Much of +the Nubian region consisted of rocky shoreline. The arable lands were +restricted to a narrow fringe of alluvial deposits, which was not +encouraging enough for permanent colonization by the empires of ancient +and medieval times (ancient Egyptian, Roman, Islamic, and so on). +However, Nubia was perceived as "The Corridor to Africa" by these same +empires. This permitted the partial independence of Nubia while under +the political dominance of these empires. This unique situation enabled +the Nubians to be influenced by the belief systems of neighboring +empires, which became entangled with long-standing Nubian traditions +(Smith 2020). + +After the construction of Aswan dam in 1902, and its subsequent +heightenings in 1912 and 1933, Northern Nubian (*Kenuz*) villages, were +submerged under the Nile waters. This submersion forced the *Kenuz* +Nubians to rebuild their houses at higher levels each time. Also, most +of the agricultural land in *Kenuz* villages became inundated for most +of the year. Cultivation was only possible along a narrow strip of the +plain for two months during the summer. This impoverishment forced +Nubian men to migrate to Egyptian cities in search for work, while women +and children were left behind in Nubia. + +Despite the heightenings of Aswan dam, the effects of the Nile flooding +were devastating along the Valley and the Delta villages causing much +loss in life and property. Therefore, the new Egyptian regime in 1954 +decided to build the High Dam, a new dam in Aswan higher than the +already existing one. This meant that the entirety of Nubia was to be +submerged under the lake created behind the new dam. So, it was decided +to relocate the Nubians to the Kom Ombo area, 50 km north of Aswan City. +This resettlement plan compacted the Egyptian Nubia from thirty-nine +villages along 320 kilometers of the Nile into thirty-three villages +occupying a 60-kilometer-long crescent away from the Nile in the desert. +Several studies discussed the challenges of the Nubian resettlement +after displacement, however, these studies focused on "home-building" +issues and the wide dissatisfaction among the Nubians towards their new +houses and resettlements, but these studies say very little on +"home-making" practices and efforts undertaken by the Nubians aftermath +their displacement. + +The experience of forced displacement deeply unsettles the +taken-for-granted notions of home. When the displaced person lives in a +new place, he/ she does not feel like home automatically. Home is much +more than a house or a shelter, rather it is a complex and multi-layered +concept. Some of these layers are existential; the "immersion of a self +in a locality" (Brah 1996). Home is a physical place that embodies the +state of being-at-home with its particular emotions; privacy, +familiarity, safety/comfort, control, the expression of personal +identity and the social norms and values of his community. Thus, home +does not simply exist but is made and lived. The term home-making +implies a process that turns a meaningless space into a home. Material +and social practices of home-making are undertaken to overcome the +displacement gap by reflecting one's expectations not only in his/ her +new house, but also the larger public environment in the neighborhood +and the city. Home is materially made by building structures, placing +furniture and decorating the house. Home is socially made through both +routinized and seasonal social practices including; domestic chores, +caring of the household members, relaxation, celebrating birthdays and +religious rituals, communicating with neighbors and so on. + +In this research, I explore how the people of Abu Hor, a Kenuz Nubian +village, could remake their homes and homeland aftermath their +displacement in December 1964. Drawing on the scholarship on home-making +practices in diverse contexts of displacement, as well as +auto-ethnographic research based on narratives from elderly people who I +used to talk, listen, and even gossip with them to understand the +techniques they had developed to deal with the new home life in +resettlement, a life that was far from the lives they had already known, +a life which made different demands that they never had experienced +before. The research begins with an explanation of the built environment +of Old Abu Hor and the socio-cultural values that created and ordered +this environment. Then, the research focuses on the different material +and social practices that they used to create a sense of home in New Abu +Hor. Finally, the research ends with an analysis of the home-making +process based on the framework of Maurice Garcia (2019), who proposed +that the sense of home can be remade in terms of four aspects: material +place, familiar landscape, social world and emotional space. The +conclusion of the research underscores the main outcomes of the +home-making process with its challenges as well as resolutions, +continuities as well as discontinuities. + +**Before displacement** + +My family originated from a small Kenuz Nubian village called (Abu Hor). +The old Abu Hor was located about sixty kilometers south of the city of +Aswan, near Kalabsha village and its famous temple. The post steamboat +was the only means of transportation linking Nubian villages to Egypt, +starting from the village of Al-Shalal in Aswan to Wadi Halfa on the +Egyptian-Sudanese border, passing through all the Egyptian Nubian +villages. This steamboat used to pass by our village on Wednesdays +coming from Aswan and on Mondays returning from Halfa. It carried +passengers, goods, letters, and money orders from migrating men to their +families in the village. + +Kawthar Abd El-Rasoul and Mohamed Riad visited the village in 1962 and +described it. Their description is worth quoting at length: + +> "This was the first time we saw Abu Hor on a summer morning, and the +> view was beautiful, (...) , the Nile had dropped below its winter +> level by about twenty meters or a little less, and we were in Little +> Linda raising our eyes to a rock wall more than fifty meters high, and +> at the foot of the rock wall, there was a green strip no more than +> fifty meters wide, and on top of the rocks were scattered high houses, +> and due to the height, we could only see the edges of their decorated +> walls for long distances. +> +> After about half an hour, the rock wall of Abu Hor retreated in a +> large arc, and opened up into a small agricultural basin whose depth +> did not exceed one hundred and fifty meters inward. The cultivated +> areas in this small plain did not exceed several narrow strips, while +> green grass covered the remaining areas. Numbers of camels, perhaps +> more than twenty-five camels, and numbers of goats and sheep spread +> throughout the area. +> +> A little before four o\'clock we reached the hamlets of Abu Hor; The +> Nile is much narrower, the eastern plateau is high and continuous for +> kilometers, the western bank is less high and continuous and consists +> of groups of unconnected hills. (...) We rested a little on the west +> bank and saw many flying fish (2014, 68, 132)." + +![Photograph of Old Abu Hor in 1962 showing camels in front of the village.](../static/images/sadeq/fig1.jpg "Photograph of Old Abu Hor in 1962. Source: Riad, M. and Abdel-Rasoul, K. (2014), A journey in the time of Nubia.") + +**~~Figure 1. Photograph of Old Abu Hor in 1962. Source: Riad, M. and Abdel-Rasoul, K. (2014), A journey in the time of Nubia.~~** + + +Abu Hor extended for ten kilometers and included twenty-three hamlets +built on the rugged lands at the eastern and western fringes of the +valley, leaving the narrow plain for agriculture. These hamlets extended +thinly along the Nile and were separated from each other by topographic +features like *khor*[^1] and steep hills. During the summer, as the +water level of the Nile used to recede, *khor* lands became visible and +people often moved between the hamlets by donkey or on foot. In winter, +the water of the Aswan reservoir filled the valley and backed up into +the *khor*s, making hamlets sites like peninsulas, so small felucca +sailboats ferried the people across the hamlets. + +Since most social relations were associated with hamlets, the village +lacked the real structure of a social unit. Even so, the village had a +role of cohesiveness. It served as an administrative unit under the +supervision of a governmental appointed mayor (Arabic: *omda*) whose +guesthouse was the place where the people of Abu Hor gathered to make +crucial decisions that concerned the entire village. The old village had +three primary schools, a telegraph office, and a health center. These +facilities were distributed among the different hamlets, and served not +only the people of Abu Hor, but also the adjacent villages. + +![Map of the hamlets of Abu Hor village in 1930. Source: United Nations Archives at Geneva, Survey of Egypt, Kalabsha, 1935.](../static/images/sadeq/fig2.jpg "Map of the hamlets of Abu Hor village in 1930. Source: United Nations Archives at Geneva, Survey of Egypt, Kalabsha, 1935.") + +**~~Figure 2. Map of the hamlets of Abu Hor village in 1930. Source: United Nations Archives at Geneva, Survey of Egypt, Kalabsha, 1935.~~** + +The people of Abu Hor belonged to seven tribes, or maximal lineages, +which were divided among major lineages distributed over hamlets. Each +hamlet (Arabic: *nag'*) consisted of minor lineages forming a +patrilineal descent group that had lived in the hamlet for generations +and shared kinship ties. The *nag'* created a sense of belonging, as +people used to refer to themselves by their hamlet and particular +descent group, which were believed to express pride and distinctive +personalities. + +The *nag'* served as the main social unit that formed the Nubian +society. It was the actual unit of community life that was organized +through propinquity and kinship bonds and carried important social +obligations; such as endogamous marriage, purchase on credit, mutual aid +in times of need, and taking care for the families of migrating men. The +*nag'* served as the appropriate domain for women to participate in +social life. While men were more concerned with village affairs and +could move freely between hamlets and villages, women were restricted to +their *nag'* where they practiced social and economic activities, +ranging from subsistence farming and raising livestock to participating +in *nag'* events such as weddings, funerals, and religious rituals. + +The *nag'* offered the pattern of co-residence that maintained the +isolated and conservative life of the Nubians so as the foreigner could +be identified easily. Although there was no structural plan, the *nag'* +was a planned settlement, designed by its occupants according to their +needs and culture. The placement of the dwellings was based on family +ties and the natural environment as well. It was customary for +individuals to build their houses on any even tract of land adjacent to +their relatives in order to have help nearby in case of need. The +dwellings that made up the *nag'* followed the natural contours of the +rocky fringes of the valley. The houses that overlooked the Nile were +detached, or semi---detached, forming clustered terraces, while the +houses that extended inland were freestanding and grouped together +around an open area. Usually there were three or four houses in each of +these arrangements. In the center of the *nag'*, there was a large open +space where the mosque and few shops were located. The communal +guesthouse (Arabic: *sabeel*) which used for the *nag'* men gatherings, +entertaining and housing male guests from other hamlets or villages was +also placed in the central open space. Each *nag'* also maintained a +cemetery and a shrine for the local saint in its hinterland. + +The traditional house in Old Nubia was not only a shelter, but it was +also the center of most Nubian rites. The design of the house had a +strong connection to the natural environment, especially to the +topography and the climate. It also reflected Nubian social norms and +the economic condition of the proprietor. A typical house in old Abu Hor +might be composed of a big walled courtyard with rooms built at the +northern part of the courtyard, while the main entrance and the loggia +were often located in the southern part and were open to the north in +order to allow the best possible access to north wind. Livestock +enclosures were found in the southern part of the courtyard as well, but +with a separate entrance. Guest rooms were not common in Abu Hor houses, +however, the entrance hall and the bench (Arabic: *mastaba*) built near +the entrance gate served the purpose of the guest room. The entrance +hall was a transitional zone between the semi-public, male domain +outside, and the private, female domain inside the house. The courtyard +was the vital part of the traditional Nubian house. It was not just an +empty space; rather, it was the hub for all female activity such as +baking *dooka* bread, grinding cereals, and raising livestock. The +courtyard also served as a guest area for women to meet, especially on +the occasion of weddings, funerals, and other events. + +![Plan of a house in Abu Hor village in 1964. Source: Jaritz, H. (1973), Notes on Nubian Architecture.](../static/images/sadeq/fig3.jpg "Plan of a house in Abu Hor village in 1964. Source: Jaritz, H. (1973), Notes on Nubian Architecture.") + +**~~Figure 3. Plan of a house in Abu Hor village in 1964. Source: Jaritz, H. (1973), Notes on Nubian Architecture.~~** + +Nubian ceremonies are the most noticeable and distinct feature of the +Nubian culture. It has reflected its rich and intermingled history +through the ages. As Muslims, the Nubians celebrated the known Islamic +feasts; *Eid al-fitr* or the Small Feast and *Eīd* *al-adaha* or the +Large Feast. In these occasions, the hamlet (*nag'*) was the ritual unit +where all rites were performed. After, the Eid prayer, the men used to +make a procession to each house in their own hamlet to congratulate +their relatives for the feast. However, the Nubians had two ceremonies +that can be considered as distinctively Nubian; the wedding ceremonies, +and the local Islamic celebrations *moulid*. + +Marriage rituals varied between seven and fourteen days in length; the +rituals used to start right after a new marriage was arranged and +announced, all the women and young females living in the *nag'* were +expected to assemble in the house of the bride\'s family to assist in +grinding the wheat to make *shaʼreya*[^2], while the men would visit the +groom to congratulate him. + +Before marriage, the bride, dressed in her bridal gown and accompanied +by an elderly female relative, had to visit all the houses around the +*nag'* to announce the day for starting the wedding ceremonies. In turn, +the women offered gifts of *karej*[^3] or a china plate. Then the bride +would continue on to visit all the major saints\' shrines in the village +and to *Abu Asha* shrine in the adjacent village, *Murwaw*. The groom, +dressed in his bridal attire, carrying a whip, riding a camel and +accompanied by the *arras*[^4], had to visit all the guesthouses in the +village to invite the men of other hamlets to his wedding. Wedding +ceremonies were occasions for three days and nights of feasting and +dancing in both the bride\'s and the groom\'s houses. On the morning of +the wedding day (the third day of wedding ceremonies), the relatives and +friends of the groom would bring his *sandouq* *jally* and hung the +*kojara* in the bride\'s house. After the guests had eaten the *fatta* +lunch at the groom\'s house, they would form a procession with the +groom\'s family to the local shrine before going to the bride\'s house, +passing in front of the *nag'* houses while sessions of singing and +dancing were carried on accompanied by gunshots and cries of joy. + +![A picture of sandouq jally.](../static/images/sadeq/fig4.jpg "A picture of sandouq jally.") + +**~~Figure 4. A picture of sandouq jally.~~** + +The local Saints (Arabic: *sheikh*) have an important ritual ceremony +called *moulid*, a festival day designated as the *sheikh's* birthday, +usually on the fifteenth of the Islamic month of *Shaʼbān*. The *moulid* +was both a religious and social occasion that was celebrated by men, +women and children, and reunited many of the city migrants with their +relatives in the village. The whole *nag'* used to combine their +financial resources in order to host the ceremonies, demonstrating their +generosity and prestige among other hamlets. From the early morning of +the *moulid* day, boatloads of people from neighboring villages along +with the village residents made long processions to the square of the +saint\'s shrine, where the men sang *zikr* and danced the *kaff* dance, +the women offered sacrificial goats and sheep to be slaughtered, cooked +and eaten in the communal feast afterwards, and the children enjoyed the +joyful atmosphere and bought sweets and toys from travelling vendors. + +**After displacement** + +On the 27^th^ of December 1963, the displacement of the people of Abu +Hor began to their village in New Nubia, where the new Abu Hor is one of +the five villages that are under the administrative local council of +Kalabsha, a main village which provides the neighboring villages with +social, educational and administrative services. + +The new Abu Hor was planned according to a grid pattern; the main +streets were oriented north-south and secondary streets crossed at right +angles. In the first phase of resettlement, the houses were +significantly smaller than in Old Nubia and were arranged back-to-back +in long rows based on four prototypes of houses that ranged from one to +four bedrooms. These houses were distributed according to family size; +however, this arrangement ignored the socio-spatial structure +characteristic of the Nubian villages before displacement. Relatives and +the elderly who had lived nearby in old Nubia were allocated houses far +from each other. And women, who were confined to their hamlet, found +themselves surrounded by strange neighbors from other hamlets. For +instance, my paternal grandfather (Sayed) was assigned a +three-bedroom-house away from the house of his grandfather (Ali). Thus, +the new settings in resettlement disturbed the established social fabric +of the village. + +Moreover, many families didn't even receive a house in the first phase +of resettlement, so they had to live with relatives in their new small +houses. This situation was further exacerbated after the 1967 war, when +the migrant families who were living in Suez, Ismailia, and Port Said +had to evacuate these cities and moved back to New Abu Hor to live with +their relatives. This crowdening even worsened the living conditions in +the new village. + +![Layout of New Abu Hor.](../static/images/sadeq/fig6.jpg "Layout of New Abu Hor.") + +**~~Figure 6. Layout of New Abu Hor.~~** + + +In 1970, my mother\'s family received their house (Faris' house in +Figure 6) as one of the second phase typical houses; a +thirteen-by-twenty-meter house that consisted of a courtyard, two small +bed rooms, a kitchen, and a bathroom. The walls were made of limestone +cut from nearby quarries, with 0.40m thickness and 3-meter height, while +the flat roof was made of reinforced concrete to allow the building of a +second storey using the bearing walls technique. However, this house +form disregarded the climatic and social considerations characteristic +of the traditional Nubian house. The kitchen was so small that there was +no space to store food and supplies. The rooms were also much smaller +than their house in Old Abu Hor, which prevented them from having enough +space for sleeping or socializing. The placement of the rooms along the +southern side of the house allowed the heat to penetrate into them, in +addition to the heat that came in from the uninsulated roof. Surrounded +by other houses on three sides, the northern winds could not reach the +house, making the living conditions intolerable during the summer +months. + +They had to make alterations in the house in order to suit their way of +life. A larger kitchen was built to be spacious enough for cooking and +storing dried food and supplies, while the former kitchen had become a +bedroom, in addition to building a new room for the children and +enclosures for goats and chicken. As in Old Nubia, the façade was +whitewashed, and the low clay bench mastaba was built in front of the +house, adding more space for hospitality and neighbors\' gatherings. +Aside from cooking and cleaning the house, the daily activities after +relocation ranged between fetching water from the installed public taps +and shopping at Seyalla's weekly market. Occasionally, they spent their +afternoons on their farmland, where they planted palm trees and a +Roselle shrub. + +![My grandparents\' house before and after alterations.](../static/images/sadeq/fig7.jpg "My grandparents\' house before and after alterations.") + +**~~Figure 7. My grandparents\' house before and after alterations.~~** + +The people of Abu-Hor tried to recreate the sense of community in their +new village through undertaking several cooperative projects. Every row +of houses cooperated in cleaning the street, plastering the facades and +planting trees. The whole village collected money to build a communal +guesthouse (*sabeel*) not only for accommodating visitors, but also as a +gathering place where men can meet in the evening, gather in ritual +feasts, and hold public meetings. The people of Abu-Hor cooperated in +celebrating religious rituals + +An elderly woman, who was a custodian of a saint's shrine in the Old Abu +Hor, built a shrine in the new village. Some women, especially in the +first years after relocation, were visiting this shrine to make vows and +offer sacrificial sheep and goats as in Old Nubia. Also, the custodian +of the shrine held moulids for the saint on the fifteen of Shaaban, and +few people in the village celebrated it. But the biggest moulid after +relocation was the "Five Domes" moulid in Murwaw village, which hundreds +of Kenuz men, women, and children celebrated by singing zikr, dancing +kaff, and communal feast as in Old Nubia. + +**Discussion** + +The Nubian house was rooted in the natural landscape on which it was +built. It embodied the social world of Nubian society with its basic +values and hierarchies. The house was spatially organized to invert the +fundamental oppositions within Nubia: North/ South, Nile/ mountain, +public/ private, male/ female, human/ animal. Moreover, the domestic +spatial divisions enabled inhabitants to practice traditional Nubian +rituals, especially for women. In wedding ceremonies, for instance, the +women of the *nag'* gathered in the courtyard of the bride's house to +participate in a seven-day ritual period of cooking, singing, dancing +and feminine visitation. Similarly, other life-cycle rituals were +practiced by women domestically. Thus, the courtyard had to be wide +enough to accommodate the guests attending these ceremonies. The Nubian +house functioned as a generative mechanism for the Nubian culture, +underwriting habitus and reproducing its elements for the inhabitants. +As Bourdieu and Sayad stated (1964: 26) "the structure of habitat is the +symbolic projection of the most fundamental structures of a culture." + +The Nubian house served as the centerpiece of all Nubian social +organization. The spatial configurations separated the house from the +patrilineal agglomeration (*nag'*) and the *nag'* from other +agglomerations. These divisions reflected the Nubian social hierarchy in +a unitary symbolic order. Thus, the traditional Nubian house and village +were the reflection of the Nubian culture, where all life functions +occur in harmony. + +However, the Nubian social life with its infinite rhythm faced a sudden +and dramatic transformation after the construction of the High Dam in +1964. The resettlement policies that relocated entire Nubian people +placed them in a very different social and architectural setting; +planned villages in the desert removed from the Nile. Displacement as +experienced by Nubians driven from their homes and from their homeland, +overturned the Nubian social organization. Such transformations in +domestic space had an indelible effect on their culture. + +Following displacement, as people are forced to leave their homelands, a +place where they had felt socially, culturally and emotionally embedded, +they are likely to experience a sense of loss of community, history, and +identity. Thus, emplacement is not simply re-placing people in new +place, but it is a continuous process of making one's place in the +world. Emplacement implies the social processes, relations and +encounters through which displaced people engage with the new +environment, and therefore transform the new place into a personalized +and socialized one. Emplacement emphasizes the concept of place as a +process of embeddedness and socio-affective attachment, and also +emphasizes the role of displaced people in place-making processes. + +The loss of a home due to displacement is such a socially disorienting, +disempowering and disruptive process that remaking one involves a +lengthy effort with no obvious start or end point. The process of +remaking a home entails more than building a physical place of shelter +and finding a source of livelihood. It requires inhabitants to establish +a feeling of being "'at home" (Hage's, 1997: 102). This process of +feeling at home involves four dimensions; a material place, a familiar +landscape, a social world, and an emotional and existential place. + +The home is not only a place where individuals can satisfy their basic +needs and protect themselves from harm threatening otherness (weather +conditions, animals, people). It is also a place where dwellers can take +control of their own boundaries and express their personal and social +identities within the home. Living in a place in which individuals have +no control or ability to express themselves and cannot change the +furnishings or the decorations can be deeply frustrating. It compromises +their ability to feel at home. Houses are seldom built by their +inhabitants. Thus, it is the ornamentation, maintenance, housework, +identification, and personalization processes that people enact to +transform a house into a home. According to Bourdieu, domestic space is +appropriated by the resident according to a system of customs that are +generated by past residential experience which he called \"habitus\". +Thus, the acts of appropriation and identification from past experience +not only connect individuals spatially with the places in which they +dwell, but also connect them with the past and the future. + +Regaining the sense of being at home was also achieved through +familiarization with the new milieu, including its geographical and +social features. This is a process whereby strange places and people +become familiar. This process involved different scales of place, from +the specific home to the whole village. The meaningless house is +transformed into a home through daily practices and repetitive behavior +in everyday life events. The actions create familiarity and therefore a +sense of home. + +> Becoming at home is linked to the "refrain," a form of expression with +> a different meaning every time it is repeated, as a song ventures +> forward with each verse before returning to the refrain (Dovey, 2010, +> 18). + +Familiarity is also created when people possess a maximal spatial +knowledge of the new village and its features become familiar through +daily movement along the same paths, which Michel de Certeau called "The +opacity of the body." + +> In movement, gesticulating, walking, taking its pleasure, is what +> indefinitely organizes a here in relation to an abroad, a +> \"familiarity\" in relation to a \"foreignness\" (Leach, 2016, 299). + +As Korac (2009: 42) stresses, "emplacement does not take place in a +social vacuum; rather it occurs within the context of intra- and +inter-group relations." Creating a sense of home in New Abu-Hor required +reconstructing a social world in the new village based on shared +traditions and values after centuries of belonging to *nag'* kin groups. +Reconstructing the social world aimed to regaining a sense of belonging +to a community, where "one recognizes people as 'one's own' and where +one feels recognized by them as such." + +Through everyday social practices, visiting and chatting with neighbors +in *mastaba*, the people of Abu-Hor could create new social attachments +within the place of resettlement, thus creating a sense of home. +Building the village guesthouse (*Sabeel*) was another way the people of +Abu-Hor could reconstruct their social world, by creating "new material +forms which symbolize a former community" (Schultze,2020, 291). The +guesthouse could be conceived as a "memorialized locale" (Lofland, 1998, +65) which symbolizes the lifestyle of the past culture. + +Displacement involved separating from a place that Nubians described as +"homely," a place where they had felt emotionally embedded. Displacement +was an experience full of emotional distress; whether grief for the +place left behind, the struggle of living in the present or worrying for +the future. This emotional distress of being displaced remained until +people were able to remake emotional attachments in the new village. +However, the reconstruction of the emotional feeling of being at home +did not happen automatically; for a long time, people continued to +reflect on differences between the old Abu-Hor and the new village. + +The people of Abu-Hor could reconstruct the emotional feeling of being +at home by replicating their social and cultural traditions of Old Nubia +in the new village; such as life-cycle rituals and celebrating religious +ceremonies. Although the new setting lacked the geographical features in +which these traditions were practiced -- the Nile, mountains, old +shrines, and so on -- creativity and imagination helped them to +reproduce cultural traditions by evoking the landscape that they were +forced to abandon. As Obeid writes (2013: 374), "what seems like a +yearning for the past can contribute very much to the creation of the +present and the future." + +**Conclusion** + +For more than fifteen centuries, Egyptian Nubians had lived in isolated +villages on the banks of the Nile, surviving the harsh environment and +the competing empires, and had slowly developed a distinctive culture +that successfully responded to numerous crises. However, the building of +the High Dam and the subsequent resettlement of Nubians in a desert +habitat has been the greatest shock to their culture that has been +characterized by continuity and change. Yet Nubian culture did not +collapse by the backwaters of the High Dam, the vitality and flexibility +of the Nubians helped them to adjust to the different natural and social +milieu while retaining a strong sense of their historical and cultural +identity. + +The idea that Nubia no longer exists made the (re)production of homeland +as a mythical place necessary for maintaining their identity. This +research illustrated the varied strategies undertaken by Nubians to +reconstruct homeland in new settlements. These strategies included +houses alterations, symbolic recreation of places depicting the places +in Old Nubia such as the shrine and the community guesthouse, practicing +Nubian rituals and celebrating religious and social ceremonies. All +these strategies were significant in transforming the unfamiliar +resettlement place into a home. + +Former narratives of Nubians displacement were often colored by rosy +view of Old Nubia, which became a mythical place to which Nubians still +long to return. Such narratives emanates from the static and fixed +Heideggerian ontology of being-in-the-world, which conceive of home and +homeland as a place of rootedness. However, the Nubian displacement, and +other experiences of displacement worldwide, challenge this discourse. +Even after displacement disrupted people's social worlds-- the +individuals' sense of being at home and their social relations -- the +displaced are often able to recreate home, or what Naila Habib (1996) +calls "the evolving meaning of home" as "a dynamic and constantly +changing process." This dynamic notion of home denotes that belonging to +a place can be understood as fluid territorialisation -- in the +Deleuzian sense -- through giving meaning to the place by individual and +collective behavior, which reminds us of Appadurai\'s (1995) thesis on +the production of locality. According to this thesis, a locality is not +a given, but it is created by social practices, ritual activities, and +the collective effort of the community in order to socialize the space +and localize the people. In the case of Abu Hor, villagers turned to +traditional practices in addition to building of a shrine and a +community guesthouse in the new village, which illustrates this process +of (re)construction not only of Abu Hor but also of the bond between the +people and their new locality. + +Indeed, this research does not aim to romanticize nor to underestimate +the precarious circumstances of Nubian displacement. Instead, the +intention of this research is to acknowledge the significance of +Nubians' contributions to produce alternative meanings within the +modularization of their new top - built environment. Rather than +associating the Nubian displacement merely with loss and passivity, this +research discussed the resiliency and the spatial practices through +which Nubians could contribute to processes of homemaking and +(re)territorialisation on different spatial scales. + +**Bibliography:** + +Appadurai, Arjun. "The Production of Locality." In Counterwork: Managing +the Diversity of Knowledge, edited by Richard Fardon. London: Routledge, +1995. + +Brah, Avtar. *Cartographies of Diaspora: Contesting Identities*. London: +Rouledge, 1996. + +Bourdieu, Pierre and Sayad, Abdelmalek. *Le Déracinement. La Crise de +l'agriculture traditionelle en Algérie*. Paris: Minuit, 1964. + +Dovey, Kim. *Becoming Places*. Abingdon, Oxon; New York, NY: Routledge, +2010. + +Habib, Naila. "The Search for Home." *Journal of Refugee Studies* 9 +(1996): pp. 96--102. + +Hassan, Abu-bakr Mahjoub and Hassan, Mohamed Mahjoub. *Abu- Hor Our +Homeland*. Khartoum: The Nubian Studies and Documentation Center, 2000. + +Jaritz, Horst. "Notes on Nubian Architecture." In *Nubians in Egypt: +Peaceful People*, edited by Robert A. Fernea. Austin and London: +University of Texas Press, 1973: pp. + +Korac, Maja. *Remaking Home: Reconstructing Life, Place and Identity in +Rome and Amsterdam*. New York and Oxford: Berghahn Books, 2009. + +Leach, Neil. "Belonging: Towards a Theory of Identification with Space." +In *Habitus: A Sense of Place,* edited by Jean Hillier and Emma Rooksby. +Abingdon, Oxon; New York, NY: Routledge, 2016: pp. 297-313. + +Lofland, Lyn H. *The public realm: Exploring the city's quintessential +social territory. Communication and social order*. Hawthorne and New +York: Aldine de Gruyter, 1998. + +Obeid, Michelle. "Home-Making in the Diaspora Bringing Palestine to +London." In *Diaspora and Transnational Studies Companion*, edited by +Ato Quayson, and Girish Daswani. Hoboken, NJ: John Wiley & Sons, 2013: +pp. 366--80. + +Perez Murcia, Luis Eduardo. "Remaking a Place Called Home Following +Displacement." In *The* *Routledge Handbook* *of* *Place*, edited by Tim +Edensor, Ares Kalandides, and Uma Kothari. Abingdon, Oxon; New York, NY: +Routledge, 2020: pp. 468-76. + +Riad, Mohamed and Abd el-Rasoul, Kawthar. *A journey in the time of +Nubia*. Windsor: Hindawi Foundation, 2014. + +Schultze, Henrik. "The Symbolic Construction of Community Through +Place." In *The* *Routledge Handbook* *of* *Place*, edited by Tim +Edensor, Ares Kalandides, and Uma Kothari. Abingdon, Oxon; New York, NY: +Routledge, 2020: pp. 285-93. + +Smith, Stuart T. "Colonial Entanglements: Imperial Dictates and +Intercultural Interaction in Nubia." In *Archaeologies* *of Empire: +Local Participants and Imperial Trajectories,* edited by Anna L. Boozer, +B.S. Düring, and B.J. Parker. Santa Fe, NM: SAR & UNM Press, 2020: pp. +21-56. + +United Nations Archives at Geneva, Survey of Egypt, Kalabsha, 1935. + + +Hassan Fathy, + +[^1]: []{dir="rtl"}Khor: an Arabic word stands for a natural swale + cutting through the desert plateau at right angles to the Nile. + +[^2]: Shaʼreya: a vermicelli-like food with milk and sugar which was + served as breakfast to the guests and to the bride and groom after + the wedding. + +[^3]: []{dir="rtl"}Karej: Nubian traditional plates weaved of brightly + colored palm fiber strips. + +[^4]: Arras: a young boy relative of the groom who accompanied him + everywhere for the whole week prior to the wedding. His role was to + serve the groom and "guard" him from his friends\' pranks. diff --git a/content/author/abdelsadeq.md b/content/author/abdelsadeq.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..0919860 --- /dev/null +++ b/content/author/abdelsadeq.md @@ -0,0 +1,8 @@ +--- +title: Amany Abdelsadeq Sayed Hussein +affiliation: Independent researcher +--- + +# Biography + +Amany Abdelsadeq Sayed Hussein is \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/static/images/sadeq/Bilde3.jpg b/static/images/sadeq/Bilde3.jpg new file mode 100644 index 0000000..ab15cec Binary files /dev/null and b/static/images/sadeq/Bilde3.jpg differ diff --git a/static/images/sadeq/Bilde4.jpg b/static/images/sadeq/Bilde4.jpg new file mode 100644 index 0000000..9827360 Binary files /dev/null and b/static/images/sadeq/Bilde4.jpg differ diff --git a/static/images/sadeq/Bilde6.jpg b/static/images/sadeq/Bilde6.jpg new file mode 100644 index 0000000..32adb64 Binary files /dev/null and b/static/images/sadeq/Bilde6.jpg differ diff --git a/static/images/sadeq/Bilde7.jpg b/static/images/sadeq/Bilde7.jpg new file mode 100644 index 0000000..ef82c70 Binary files /dev/null and b/static/images/sadeq/Bilde7.jpg differ diff --git a/static/images/sadeq/fig1.jpg b/static/images/sadeq/fig1.jpg new file mode 100644 index 0000000..0367366 Binary files /dev/null and b/static/images/sadeq/fig1.jpg differ diff --git a/static/images/sadeq/fig2.jpg b/static/images/sadeq/fig2.jpg new file mode 100644 index 0000000..59b9d13 Binary files /dev/null and b/static/images/sadeq/fig2.jpg differ diff --git a/static/images/sadeq/fig3.jpg b/static/images/sadeq/fig3.jpg new file mode 100644 index 0000000..642fd8e Binary files /dev/null and b/static/images/sadeq/fig3.jpg differ diff --git a/static/images/sadeq/fig4.jpg b/static/images/sadeq/fig4.jpg new file mode 100644 index 0000000..d3da2cb Binary files /dev/null and b/static/images/sadeq/fig4.jpg differ diff --git a/static/images/sadeq/fig6.jpg b/static/images/sadeq/fig6.jpg new file mode 100644 index 0000000..967523c Binary files /dev/null and b/static/images/sadeq/fig6.jpg differ diff --git a/static/images/sadeq/fig7.jpg b/static/images/sadeq/fig7.jpg new file mode 100644 index 0000000..264eb55 Binary files /dev/null and b/static/images/sadeq/fig7.jpg differ